4

I've been practising Mahler's 5th Symphony for quite a while now on the piano (the transcription/arrangement by Otto Singer II) and I recently realized that I was playing a D instead of a D-flat, which is what the notes actually suggest:

enter image description here

This is a passage from the third movement (the Scherzo). When playing it again with a D-flat it sounded so off compared to what I had heard countless times listening to this recording that I had to go back and check:

Bernstein - Mahler 5

No matter how many times I replay that part I keep hearing a regular D. The same goes for this one conducted by Barenboim. I did read this question about why some recordings seem to be in a different key, but that is not the case with this question. It's literally just this one note during this passage.

Am I hearing this correctly? - I don't have perfect pitch but this seems pretty clear to me - Am I wrong? Are both my ears and my piano so far out of tune? I have a strong feeling that I'm missing something pretty simple here, but what?

I also thought that it might just be a transcription error so I looked into the orchestra score but that one also says D-flat:

enter image description here

5

The first edition of the score (Peters, 1904) has D naturals.

enter image description here The Peters "revised edition" (also dated 1904, but issued in 1905) has D flats.

The Peters Urtext edition (1964) has gone back to D naturals.

"Revised" doesn't always mean "better"!

All three editions are on IMSLP.

2

The individual parts on IMSLP are from a different edition, and have accidentals turning those notes into D♮'s:

enter image description here

(From the Flute I part, p. 9.)

Which version is "right" I can't say, but at least you know that you're not going crazy.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.