0

This question already has an answer here:

In the diatonic scale of C, the progression is 1, 1, 1/2, 1, 1, 1/2 tones. What is the origin behind this progression and why is this made that way and not any other form such as 1-1/2-1-1-1-1-1/2?

The music theory usually explain well the temperament and the diatonic scale, but it does not explain why a Piano misses two black keys or why the black keys are arranged in such way.

marked as duplicate by leftaroundabout, Tim, Todd Wilcox, Bradd Szonye, Matthew Read Jan 26 '17 at 7:08

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • I'm certain this has been asked already, but can't find it! However, the piano doesn't miss two black keys - they were never there! – Tim Jan 25 '17 at 8:52
4

The current major scale has a couple of nice properties: It contains only two types of intervals, the smaller interval is closely related to the larger (one-half), the intervals are neither too small nor too large for convenient singing and hearing, and it contains the 7 pitches most closely related to each other.

"Most closely related" here means that if you keep going up a fifth (the simplest non-trivial interval) from a given pitch, then the first six other pitches you get will eventually fill the entire major scale (when transposed back into the octave of the starting pitch). (If you keep going, after 12 steps you get the entire chromatic scale.)

Note that this is not exactly the way the Western tone system actually evolved. Instead, development went through stages of scales with five and six notes which were not the five most closely related ones. However, now that we have the major/minor system it has proven to be a very convenient choice and a great 'attractor', so that it's unlikely musicians will completely switch away to a scale built according to a different principle.

2

The diatonic major scale is indeed 1-1-½-1-1-1-½. The intervals of a tone and a semitone also appear in other scales: an ascending melodic minor scale has 1-½-1-1-½-1-1: still five tone steps and two semitones. Your suggestion of 1-½-1-1-1-1-½ is used backwards in the descending melodic minor scale.

The arrangement of tones and semitones in the diatonic major scale is exactly the scale used in one of the chant modes: it's what is variously called the Lydian or Ionian mode (Mode 5) where the fourth, if it appears, is conventionally flattened. Mode 5 is used for the joyous chants of the church like the Salve Regina or the Alma Redemptoris Mater (links to YouTube), and they do indeed sound like major-key pieces. Chants in Mode 5 tend to have been composed later than others; the chants used in those videos are later than the chants contemporary with the words (11-12th century), which are in other modes.

The ascending melodic minor scale is akin to Mode 1 (usually called Dorian), where the sixth is often flattened if it appears.

As in many evolutions, it's difficult to tell when the major scale arrived, and hence form a view on its origins. However, as Mode 5 chants tend to have been composed later (there are more from the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries than say, the tenth), it's clear that it was emerging as a standard.

A very early example of a major-key work is Sumer is icumen in, written in England in the mid-13th century. The manuscript is written in chant-like notation:

Manuscript: Sumer is icumen in

The red cross indicates where the second voice in the round should start.

The answer to "What's the origin of the diatonic major scale?" is probably "It's impossible to say," other than that mediaeval musicians thought that particular scale and its arrangement of steps sounded good.


With regard to the arrangement of keys on the piano, they are arranged so that the major scale can be played on white keys only, starting on C: starting there produces the 1-1-½-1-1-1-½ sequence. There aren't any black keys "missing" — as Tim H commented, they were never there. The gap between what are called E and F is the semitone step in the scale. Black keys were inserted within the tone steps to divide those into semitones and create a chromatic scale.

Why that particular natural scale starts on a note called C and it wasn't called something else may be better addressed in another question, but I suspect that it has something to do with the white-note minor scale starting on what is called A.

Image: London, British Library, MS Harley 978, f. 11v, via Wikipedia

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.