3

In this article Surface Topology in Bach Canons, I: The Möbius strip the author wrote that

Canon 5 is described by Bach as a duplex, a 4: there are 4 voices singing two canons in parallel.

Could you please explain for me what is a duplex? And what is a 4?

Please help me.

Thanks

  • 3
    You quoted the definition of duplex: "there are 4 voices singing two canons in parallel." – Todd Wilcox Mar 6 '17 at 5:04
  • So a 4 is also defined by 4 voices singing two canons in parallel? – Knumber10 Mar 6 '17 at 5:46
  • 1
    @Knumber10: No, a 4 simply means any four-voices piece. It could be instrumental, sung or anything and it definitely does not need to be a canon, let alone two. – guidot Mar 6 '17 at 8:31
4

duplex: just as in duplex apartment means there are two floors, here it means there are two voices/tracks to sing, probably a deeper one and a higher one.

a 4: in French and Italian (and probably latin ?), this is how you would say with 4 people. For instance, to play (a game, music, ...) with 4 people would translate to jouer à 4 in French. So it really just means 4 people are singing.

In the end the definition of duplex a 4 is exactly what you wrote: there are 4 voices singing two canons in parallel.

EDIT: 4 people re singing in total if it's a 4. Then if it's duplex you just group those people onto different voices.

  • In my opinion it is still to undefined, how the grouping is: duplex (canon à 4) which means we have 4 voices per canon and so 8 voices in total, or (duplex canon) à 4 (four voices grouped into two canons). – guidot Mar 6 '17 at 14:04
  • duplex a 4 would means there are 4 people singing in total. Which are then grouped onto two voices. Though the grouping is not defined, so it doesn't say it's two and two people, I guess you could still call a canon with 3 and 1 persons singing on each voice a duplex canon a 4 – Nicolas Marshall Mar 6 '17 at 14:28
  • Accepted for the the given example, difficult to generalize. I want to point out however, that 4 voices canon neither means, that someone sings at all, nor that each voice is only performed by one player/singer. – guidot Mar 6 '17 at 16:18
3

The phrase "duplex, a 4" is italicized, which leads me to believe it is a phrase from a different language rather than being a pair of separate terms. Looking at other places on that web page, I see there is at least one other case of italicized text in Latin ("motu recto et contrario") referring to Bach's descriptions. The phrase "duplex, a 4" could be translated from Latin as "double, from 4" or "two-fold, from 4."

When interpreted as "two canons from 4 voices," this properly matches the source text's explanation of "4 voices singing two canons in parallel."

  • Translating "a" as "by" would probably make the most sense, given the latter half of the quote. – Matthew Read Mar 6 '17 at 8:23
  • even that, what does "from 4" mean? I mean by 4 should be understood from 4 voices right? – Knumber10 Mar 6 '17 at 8:30
  • 3
    @Knumber10 Two canons sung by four voices. Two voices for each canon, as per the following sentence at your link. "Canon simplex à 3 voci" would be one canon with three voices, as another example. Here's a visualization of a canon triplex à 6 which should help; you can clearly see three pairs of voices. – Matthew Read Mar 6 '17 at 8:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.