5

Consider the percussion plays an Offbeat like
1 2 3 4 1 2 3 4

I wonder why it is so hard to interpret it as Onbeat, i.e. counting it like
_ 1 2 3 4 1 2 3

I thought it might be because of the melody (i.e. vocals), which tends to be Onbeat. However the phenomenom also occurs when I play an Offbeat on the piano without any further voices.

So my question: What makes the '1' special if not stress?

3

This depends on the context. In some styles (salsa dance music is one example), it's hard to catch the "2" beat in many pieces. Various styles distinguish breaking on 1 or on 2, but I have watched (supposed) experts miss as often as not. I do not do much better.

I have over the years noticed many dancers miss the down beat in ballroom (even waltz). Sometimes the arrangements lack a strong rhythmic feel.

However, as pointed out above, there is usually some other part of the music that carries the implication of the downbeat. Often this is the bassline, sometimes is the melody, and sometimes comes from other percussion instruments. Note that in the salsa I mentioned, the bass from beat 4 is tied to the bass on beat 1 of the next measure (with the second measure's harmony) and this is followed by the bass on the second part of beat 2, so there's no strong "2" beat for the dancers from the rhythm section.

5

Usually in this scenario another part will be playing on-beat, acting as a metronome. Either the chords in a song, perhaps the left hand part of a piano piece, or (as you correctly said), the melody.

Something more prominent will play the '1' so that any off-beat that follows, is correctly perceived as off-beat. So in your example, perhaps the off-beat section you are describing comes after an 'on-beat' section from which the listener will already have the pulse in their head, and so any off-beat notes are easily distinguished.

You said it is still hard for this to occur when there are no other voices. This will most likely be because you are already subconscious of the beat/pulse and so can tell an off-beat from an on-beat when you play it.

  • 1
    Does "subconscious" actually mean "conscious"? – anatolyg Apr 20 '17 at 11:33
  • Except, perhaps, in reggae? – Tim Apr 20 '17 at 12:30
  • For example I used to hear the intro to Bastille Pompei with the "wrong" beat, but now I can't hear it the "wrong" way, because I already know the song. – Some_Guy Apr 20 '17 at 13:10
  • @Tim I always wonder how music that emphasises the 2 and 4 can so clearly tell you where the downbeat is. Rhythm is something I tend be a lot less introspective and "theoretical" about than I am about melody or harmony, but off the top of my head I think maybe we take the bass to indicate strong beats and the treble as weak beats for some reason? So if you play a bass downbeat, you can play offbeat chords and it'll "ground" you. Almost like a rhythmic "tonic". Sorry for the crap use of terminology, here's what I mean. The bass note gives it all context onlinesequencer.net/460036 – Some_Guy Apr 20 '17 at 13:38
  • 1
    @Some_Guy - Quite a few times, when playing bass and having an empathetic drummer, I'll swap the beats, and play on 2 and 4 instead of 1 and 3 (in simple stuff). Given that the rest of the band is thinking, it is quite fun. And with reggae type numbers, it's almost obligatory... – Tim Apr 20 '17 at 13:45
0

I think the listener will jump on the first rhythmic cue that suggests the beat. In most songs, this is totally unambiguous as there is a plain and known beat established right from the beginning.

However, shifting the beat is a nice device, as discussed here (linked by Some_Guy in a comment): Intended shift of meter in certain songs? I also believe different listeners may react differently to it.

To play with it, you can listen to a metronome and force your brain to interpret the clicks as off-beats. It is possible, although your brain might work against it because it interprets the first click as an on-beat and then just keeps the pulse going. I know some drummers who use off-beat metronome to work on their timing precision.

Compare it to the spinning dancer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spinning_Dancer You may see her rotate in either direction, depending on the model you manage to establish in your brain. And you may switch at any time.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.