5

Recently I bought a second guitar, before I had for almost 8 years just one guitar and did not noticed that its action was quite high. When I took the guitars of others I often wondered that they where much more comfortable to play, but I thought it was an issue of the guitar itself and I had no idea how to adjust this. As I got my 2nd guitar I noticed the same, and also noticed that the saddle was much lower.

So I did some research and found out that replacing (or sanding) the saddle can help lowering the action, so I did this with my first guitar getting the action from 6mm down to ~4mm, see the picture:

action

But I am trying to get it even lower, but the saddle is already quite low. So I did some further research and found out that this could be achieved by adjusting the truss rod.

But before doing this, I would like to know. What bending of the neck is considered normal? I could not find any comparing pictures on the internet, so I am asking. My other guitar has also a slight bend, so I guess some curve in the neck might be normal, but I wonder what degree might be normal (so that I do not adjust my guitar wrongly)?

I also append a picture of the neck, but on it the bend is not as clearly visible as in real life:enter image description here

So what bending is normal? Or should I aim for as flat as possible?

As written here:

Ideally we are adjusting the truss rod to render the neck as flat as possible without creating too much string buzz.

and they also write the optimal action is between .004-.006in (~0.127mm, see this sheet), so their might be plenty of room to adjust my action of 4mm.

  • That 'optimal action' of 4 to 6 thou is the width of a human hair! If the guitar was adjusted so, the strings would not have room to vibrate. Taking the bottom E to be around 50 thou, you need at very least that same gap, at fret 12. – Tim May 15 '17 at 7:20
  • :D Mh... 0.004" - 0.006" are the values written in the link; I am from Europe and do not eat Quarter Pounders with cheese^^ Maybe you can enlight me and write what .004" means then... – StefanH May 15 '17 at 13:36
  • The link is merely a conversion chart. Maybe the metric figures were wrong to start with. But human hair diameter is pretty well standard, at .005", and seems way too small a figure for the action measurement. Just seen the article, and it must be wrong. – Tim May 15 '17 at 13:50
3

The three things that determine the height of a guitar's action are the nut, the saddle and the neck bow. Unless something else is wildly out of whack (like the the guitar's top lifting or the bridge peeling up), it's the neck bow that should be attended to first. Why? Well, because it works, and because you can always 'undo' an adjustment to the truss rod, but it's not so easy to restore a bit of bone/plastic that you've shaved off the saddle or nut. You've tackled the saddle first, so be aware that this will have changed the relationship between the saddle and nut heights. Don't touch the nut, though. Concentrate on the truss rod for now. The general advice for truss rod tweaking would include: loosen the strings; go slowly- a quarter turn at a time, then tune up strings and check; go gently, making sure the allen key/wrench is fully seated in the hole so you don't burr or round off the truss rod nut; never, never force it; record how many quarter turns (so you can return to the original setting), and test every string at every fret (with the guitar held in the normal playing position) for buzzing. Make sure you give it a good strum- you want to detect those buzzes. When you sight along the fingerboard it should look ever so slightly concave. If the neck looks twisted take the guitar to the repair shop or gift it to your mother in law. So in summary, try the truss rod before you attack the saddle; be aware that in changing the saddle height you affect the relationship with nut height, and make sure the fingerboard is slightly concave, not flat.

  • Thanks for the hint with leaving the strings on, I would have started taking the strings off O_o – StefanH May 15 '17 at 13:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.