3

I am going to try to learn Rachmaninoff's C minor concerto for the piano, most likely simplified. I always love the song, but what is the correct way to play it at 7:10 of the video (measures 9 and 10 after rehearsal mark 10 in the score). I see a lot of videos that play that part softy or loud and hard expressing themselves. I know it doesn't really matter but what was the original way of playing it?

3

You can find a score to this movement here at IMSLP. On page 32 of the document, you'll see that this section is marked ff:

enter image description here

With that said, this is a reprint of a score from Muzyka, and it seems that the first publication was from Gutheil. To know with 100% certainty, you'd want to check the original Gutheil score (and the autograph score from Rachmaninoff, if that exists).

2

I have a Gutheil edition - it's marked ff. I don't think I've ever heard it played any other way. Rachmanioff's own recording is a bit subdued here - more mf than ff but I think that's because of recording technology in 1929. But his tempo is interesting - much faster than Wang's. It depends on whether you think of a march in 2 or 4. Rach is definitely in 2, Wang in 4. I don't have any other recordings to compare.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.