4

I am just starting to make music and i have some limited budget that i could use to buy a midi controller, which i think is pretty nice to have. I have searched online about some midi controller that would fit my budget, and hopefully will be compatible with the stuff that i've got already.

And there are two option which fits my budget. The two have a good reviews and the price is similar. These are the options:

One has 25 keys, with 8 pads, and 8 knobs. I thought with this i could make a beat a lot easier, and modify sounds a lot more efficient with those knobs.

The other one has 49 keys, with no pads and that's pretty much it. With this i think i could write bassline easier and i have a lot more room to explore.

I'm still unsure which one i should buy, because i'm just starting out. It would be nice to have you guys' about this. Thanks

ps: im not a pro at piano nor keyboard ;P

closed as primarily opinion-based by ttw, Richard, leftaroundabout, Dave, Shevliaskovic Oct 12 '17 at 15:10

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • I'll be posting the link to the products i mentioned tomorrow, cause of reasons. – Fariz Al Wustho Oct 8 '17 at 14:56
  • 1
    Sadly I've found that pads that come in a lot of controllers are not very good. Like they just added cheap pads to say they have them. At the same time, you can use the regular keys to play drum parts. – Todd Wilcox Oct 8 '17 at 21:32
  • Discussion of specific products can be considered "off topic" on this site and can lead to a question being closed. Let's try to keep the discussion to advantages/disadvantages of pads vs. keys and considerations for a lower priced controller. – Rockin Cowboy Oct 10 '17 at 16:36
4

First, know that specific product recommendations are off-top here. But I'll point out a few points to consider as far as features.

Number of keys

Do you plan to learn piano/keys? 25 should be fine for playing most melodies or bass lines separately, but it will tough to play both at the same time as you would when learning piano. So if you only want something to record individual parts into a DAW, 25 will probably be fine. But for performing as a keyboard player would, you'd probably want 49 or more.

Key action

The key action is a matter of how hard it is to push the key down before you trigger a note. A real piano key has a bit weight to it and requires more force to push it down than a synth. This is a good thing for dynamics because it makes it easier to play the softer notes which in turn means that it's easier to play a wider dynamic range of volumes.

MIDI controllers that attempt to mimic that piano feel will be marketed as "hammer action", "fully weighted", or something similar. Those with no weight at all might call it "synth action" or avoid mentioning it altogether. In the middle is "semi-weighted".

Again this comes down to if you want to play like a piano player. If you are playing anything non-synth (piano, electric piano, etc) then being able to play dynamically is pretty important and I'd look for something with hammer or at the very least semi-weighted action. Other than that, it's up to taste. Try some out at a music store if you can to see what key feel you like.

Pads

Do you plan to play percussive sounds like drum patterns? If so pads are pretty useful. You could always use the keyboard keys as triggers. But the keyboard keys have a longer "key travel"—the time/distance between when your finger hits the key and when the note is triggered—and pads are generally more responsive and conducive to percussion parts. That said pads have a range of feels as well and just because a keyboard has pads doesn't mean they will feel good. And you can always add another, separate controller that has pads.

Knobs and Sliders

These are certainly nice if you plan to use them. Setting them up as DAW control is one thing (ex. channel faders). But if you play a lot of synth sounds it becomes really useful. Part of playing synth is manipulating the params like filter cutoff or whatever else and being able do hear those changes while you're playing is really useful. You can certainly do it in the software with a mouse after the fact but it can be hard to do it while you play without the tactile control of a knob/fader. And just as with pads, you can always add them later via another controller.

Tradeoffs

What kind of room do you have on your desk? Do you favor something more compact? Do you mind the extra price for more keys or hammer action or whatever given feature? Are you ok with something suboptimal for now with a possible upgrade down the road or would you rather spend the money to get the best one right now? There are no objective right or wrong answers and buying the right product for you usually depends on reconciling these kinds of tradeoffs.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.