6

When writing music for piano, what is the most professional-looking way to notate that you should play the right hand notes, or the top staff, during only the second time through a repeated section? Do I write just "Play 2nd time only" above the top staff? Do I write "Play top staff 2nd time only" or "Play right hand 2nd time only?" Are there any precedent examples in professional repertoire?

7

If it's just one hand that's different and the remaining hand stays the same on the repeat, then your intuition is absolutely correct. It's very common for a piece to have an instruction that says "2nd time only" next to a staff. See also Octave changes on 2nd time

Similarly, you'll occasionally see notation like mp-f which means "play mp the first time and f the second time."

Now, if you wanted both hands to be different the second time around (or a portion of the second time around), you'd consider the volta. More colloquially known as a first and second ending, the volta changes the very end of the repeated section:

enter image description here

  • Thanks. I had seen "Play 2nd time only" in some of my high school's pep band stuff, and I was curious if it was also acceptable to do so in stuff like classical or romantic music. – Christien Ayson Jan 27 '18 at 12:42
4

'Play R.H. 2ndX only' is fine. If it isn't a solo piano piece (where it's unlikely you would play NOTHING the first time round) make it especially clear that the L.H is to be played BOTH times. In fact, mark the lower stave 'play both Xs' anyway. Someone will think you want ONLY the R.H. second time.

If this is for a heavy-duty sight-reading session, write it out!

Don't worry about looking 'professional'. Worry about being clear. (Same thing, really.)

  • 6
    The '2X' is a little ambiguous, I'd say. Could be misconstrued as 'two times', although 'only' is a bit of a clue. '2nd time only' is clearer. It's just that on some gigs, there's only seconds to glance at what is to be played - you probably do a few like that ! – Tim Jan 26 '18 at 12:40
  • Indeed. Answer amended. If this is for a sight-reading gig, write it out. – Laurence Payne Jan 26 '18 at 18:10
  • Thanks. Yeah, I guess in the end, being clear is more important. – Christien Ayson Jan 27 '18 at 12:42
  • You could also write "RH tacet 1x", and then it means the same thing whether you read the 1x as "first time" or "one time". – dgatwood Jan 28 '18 at 6:28
1

One option to consider is simply writing out the two repetitions. This especially makes sense if the right hand part that is introduced on the second repetition significantly changes the feel of the phrase. Writing out both repetitions like this would have a bit more of a connotation that the two phrases are significant developments of the theme as opposed to minor variations.

  • Thanks. Yeah, I know writing out the repetition is always an option. I was just curious how often performance instructions like "Play 2nd time only" were used. – Christien Ayson Jan 27 '18 at 12:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.