1

I am a total beginner in piano(digital), though I played electric lead guitar for very long time.

I was practising the most basic hanons scales, and the instruction on book was "lift each finger as high as possible after/before hit the key"

I'm a bit confused because on guitar over the years I'm conditioned to move my fingers as less as possible during fast scales, very minimum finger lifting from fretboard, and the lightest touch that its just enough to press the string.

So my question is, this lifting each finger max is an exercise thing only? Or should I really try to play like this most of the time while playing fast scales.

p.s I understand that this also depends on the dynamic I want to achieve with the note that I press and there can no be certain rules. But what would be a good rule of thumb.

Thanks

  • I like the 'rule of thumb... – Tim May 3 '18 at 11:48
2

So my question is, this lifting each finger max is an exercise thing only? Or should I really try to play like this most of the time while playing fast scales.

It is recommended by the exercise but it is not necessary for keyboard technique more generally.

Warning: extreme fence-sitting follows:

There are several famous pedagogical approaches to keyboard playing, and they are sometimes contradictory. In general these approaches originated from observation of famous virtuosi, so all the approaches can work.

Applying to your case, some players are trained with this maximum raising of the fingers, others are not, and both approaches can work.

In general, speed is aided by minimizing unnecessary work. Raising the fingers to strike from a greater height than needed is unnecessary work and takes longer.

Fast scales, which you asked about, do not need any significant raising of the fingers. They can be played very close to the keys.

On the other hand, if the scales must be both loud and fast, some technical approaches require raising the fingers more. Others derive the increased power from arm weight and forearm rotation. I would recommend reading more on those standard terms if you are interested. This answer would grow to unreasonable length and lose focus if I wrote about them here.

Opinion follows:

I have one item of specific advice if you practise a high finger action. Make sure that your finger plunges fully into the key, and that the strength is in the playing of the key, not before; physically, that maximum acceleration occurs during depression of the key. I have seen even quite advanced pupils with a high finger action who waste most of their downstroke in just reaching the key: their playing mechanism is "too high". By the time the key begins to depress, most of the energy has been wasted. The result is a superficial "skating" on the keys and anemic tone.

  • thanks for your detailed answer. I have 2 questions back, 1-) what is the benefit of lifting fingers max during exercise? to improve finger strenght or finger independence?if so I will incorparate to my exercise schedule. 2- In general playing which approach(high or low) would you suggest to a hobbiest and which one is simpler, I don't want to create bad habits in my early days. tnx – Spring May 3 '18 at 11:11
  • 1
    1) Strength and independence are developed by the Hanon exercises. As keyboard virtuosi predate Hanon, they are therefore not mandatory. Please don't hurt yourself trying too hard to raise your fourth finger far above the third. 2) I see no difference in simplicity or difficulty of application. Both are best guided by a teacher in person. Sorry to be unhelpful but I sit on the fence quite deliberately with respect to giving far-reaching advice over the internet. My only advice is that a technique that gets the result you want with the least feeling of effort is unlikely to be bad. – user48353 May 3 '18 at 11:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.