3

FluteWhile positioning your fingers on the flute, there is one key left out between the left hand 2nd and 3rd finger. I’ve noticed that it does the same thing as the Bb Thumb Key. I prefer to use it while trilling between Bb and B, and in pieces like “Radetzky March”, where the notes after the Bb and the B are below it. It there any downside to doing so? I can change the 3rd finger to the A key relatively fast.

6

This is a classic example of "Get thee to a teacher." The flute family, like the clarinet family, sax family, and AFAIK the double reeds, have many alternate fingerings available by design. Which fingering to use depends on the passage as a whole: what fingerings must be used before and after the note in question, and what minimizes finger motion? It's always best (until you become a semi-pro quality player) to discuss fingering patterns with an experienced teacher.

As a point of possible interest: clarinets in particular have keys set up so that several notes (bottom of each range) can be played with either little finger; once in a while a passage comes along which requires one to use first one finger, then "transfer" to the other little finger within a single note!

  • 1
    I don’t have a teacher. I’m self taught. That’s why its not "Get thee to a teacher.” Its "Get thee to the internet." – NullCoderExists May 9 '18 at 13:10
  • 3
    @NullCoderExists "Never trust what you learn on the Internet" --Abraham Lincoln. If you're self-taught, I frankly shudder to think what your embouchure looks like. Self-teaching any musical instrument is at best a highly risky venture. – Carl Witthoft May 9 '18 at 13:49
  • 3
    Have to disagree (again!) with 'highly risky venture'. There are many many players, of many instruments, out there who are superb players, perhaps despite the fact that they are self-taught. On guitar and bass, I'm completely self-taught, but that hasn't stopped me facilitating hundreds, of other players, not only to play well, but showing very good exam results - if that could be considered a criterion. But I'm with you on the internet bit! Are you certain it was Abe..? – Tim May 9 '18 at 14:48
1

Don't see any downside if it's comfortable for you, and doesn't get you confused. The standard fingerings for Bb are of course going to be better for fast scale passages, etc.

1

I think this is not a good choice. With flute, your grip on the instrument is already a bit tenuous, and shifting the hand to play it in a nonstandard way could cause problems. Why not just use the normal T1--|1-- fingering?

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.