4

I'm studying harmony. Most things seem to be based on the dominant resolution, but how do I get to the V7? What other root motions can I use that are also effective?

  • 1
    Please clarify what your question is asking. It's ambiguous. – Tim Jun 8 '18 at 12:53
  • Also, it looks like there are two questions here -- "how to get to V7" and "other root motions." It may be more effective to split these into two separate questions. – General Nuisance Jun 8 '18 at 17:00
4

I think I understand your question a bit differently from the other answers. It seems to me that you're acknowledging (and rightly so) that the root motion of a descending fifth is very common in music; this is, after all, the famous V–I motion.

So it seems you're asking about other common root motions, no? Here are a few:

  • Root motion of a descending third is quite common, because it results in common tones between the two chords. Think I–vi, vi–IV, and IV–ii; all three of these progressions share two common tones between the triads.
  • Ascending third root motion does happen; think of something like I–iii. Although this progression also has two common tones between the chords, it's less common than descending third root motion.
  • Ascending motion by a step does happen, but if you're writing in the classical style, watch out for part-writing violations. I–ii, iii–IV, IV–V, and V–vi are all examples of this root motion.
  • Root motion of a descending step is relatively uncommon in the classical style, but it became very common in popular music, especially in things like the Andalusian cadence.
  • Root motion by tritone is pretty rare and often saved for special effect purposes.

The root motion by fifth you mentioned is the same as motion by fourth, by third is also by sixth, and by second is also by seventh. So the above list should exhaust all possible root motions.

2

The Bible of traditional harmony is Bach's collection of chorales.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Harmonized-Chorales-Johann-Sebastian-Bach/dp/0793525748

Any traditional hymn book comes a close second. Study a few. You'll find plenty of dominant-tonic cadences, and plenty of ways of getting to them.

enter image description here Here's one. There's a V-I cadence half way through the first line, then a 'V of V' - V one at the end of the line. In functional notation it's I I IV Ib VI IV V I (I use 'b' to indicate a first inversion. There are other ways.) Or C, C, F, C/E, Am, F, G, C in chord symbols.

Note that a lot of popular music doesn't really work this way. Traditional harmony grew out of part-writing, the chords sort of 'just happened'. Pop/rock songs are often written by guitarists, who see chords as seperate entities, and the sequences may owe more to shifting a shape up the fingerboard and thinking 'That sounds good!' than to any particular 'theory'. That's fine too!

1

I take your 'root motion dominant resolution' as V>I. Thus you're asking how to get to that V.

A couple of the most common are II>V and ii>V. Others are IV>V, Io>V and Vo>V. The II and ii having 7ths if you like.

Others are available, and a big factor is what precedes the chord which precedes V (or V7). The piece may be at a cadence where it continues straight back to I after V, or it may be modulating into V, which then effectively becomes the new I.

  • It's probably better to call II>V V/V>V, I°>V vii°/V>V, and V°>V CT°7(/V)>V, since those are the roles those first chords play in common practice period harmony. – Dekkadeci Jun 8 '18 at 14:15
  • Yes, I agree. Just tried to keep it as simple as poss. Not even sure I've answered the question... – Tim Jun 8 '18 at 14:55
0

I think you are asking about resolutions that are not dominant, right?

The second most common one is the Plagal cadence (IV I), witch is broadly used in popular music, being also part of the 4 magic chords.

There are several simple examples here.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.