11

I would like to learn to play cello, but I have a mini-disability that prevents me from turning my right hand down (palm-down, or pronation) or up (palm-up, or suspination).

How much is this going to get in the way of handling the bow? How important is pronation in the mechanics of bowing?

Additional info:

  • I can approximate rotation of the hand by altering my grasp on the bow (fingers) and lifting my elbow.

  • Wikipedia says that

    The transmission of weight from the arm to the bow happens through the pronation (inward rotation) of the forearm

but then, can I work around it with the aforementioned ‘cheats’, or would I lose too much in dexterity or sound quality?

  • My left hand is fine.
  • because you are used to using your hand that way, while you may hold the bow differently to others I will happily assure you can get many hours of enjoyment out of it. – BugFinder Jun 20 '18 at 9:49
14

IANAMPT (music physical therapist), so take this as encouragement rather than direction.

I would not let any physical disability short of losing your arm :-) stop you from trying to learn the cello. Find a decent teacher who can either work with you directly or refer you to a music-oriented physiotherapist to figure out a functional bow grip position that won't injure you. What really matters is the ability to hold the bow in the correct 3 angles (around all three x,y,z axes in space) with proper pressure and so on. If it takes a strange grip, or even some custom grip-adapter piece of hardware, so be it.

Go for it.

  • i agree, go for it. many musicians have been limited in some physical way but have made awesome music. I am not a cello history buff, but Richie Havens comes to mind on guitar, and there are countless others. – b3ko Jun 19 '18 at 13:55
  • What does IANAMPT stand for? – Cullub Jun 19 '18 at 15:32
  • I encountered a professional musician recently whose fingers only reach the first joint. It is amazing to watch him play piano. You'll be OK. – Laurence Payne Jun 19 '18 at 15:36
  • 2
    @Cullub there's an ancient IntarWebz abbreviation "IANA..." meaning "I am not a" whatever. – Carl Witthoft Jun 19 '18 at 15:51
  • 2
    @CarlWitthoft that's a good acronym to know. Otherwise when someone tells you they're not a lawyer you might be very very confused at first (and unlikely/hesitant to Google the acronym) – BruceWayne Jun 19 '18 at 17:47
5

While I have not played cello, I do (too infrequently) play upright bass. For upright, there are different ways of holding the bow. First is French, which is more palm down. And German which is more palm up.

I have played both ways, and for me I prefer the German style bows. I feel that it gives me better control and is more comfortable for my hand, wrist and arm.

I don't know if they make a German style cello bow, but the technique may work for you.

I agree with the other posts about finding a good teacher. Any good teacher will not force you into a painful position. If you experience pain, then you wont' want to play and that is not what anybody wants.

  • Interesting, I had no idea about German bow holding! It does look possible for my hand. A teacher also suggested I try the viol, but then it's suspination that I can't do. I'll definitely give your solution a try! – mcadorel Jun 19 '18 at 15:11
  • Viol players (most of which I believe are actually cellists) use in fact a backhanded style similar to German bass bowing. I once tried this on cello and it felt really weird, though it can certainly be used for old music. Using an actual bass bow is also not completely absurd – I myself use a light (French) bass bow a lot these days. You need to take a bit more care not to “squeeze the tones to death”, but with a bit practise you do also get a bit of extra oomph in the lower registers. – leftaroundabout Jun 19 '18 at 19:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.