3

Currently I'm playing in a quartet and one of the pieces we are doing is Sister Sadie.

At several times my music leaves me with a G7 for several bars with the instruction to comp - but I find it difficult to comp on a single chord for long periods of time, for example 8 bars.

How do pianists such as Horace Silver keep a single chord interesting for so long, and how can I do the same?

  • 1
    Why not answer the question by listening to what Horace Silver actually does, on your Youtube link? – user19146 Jul 15 '18 at 14:05
  • 3
    @alephzero Why not answer the question with something constructive rather than mocking it? Not everyone can listen to a piece and mimic it exactly - and anyway, I'm looking more for general advice than a transcription of what Horace plays... – FlipTack Jul 15 '18 at 16:04
  • 1
    The recording you posted is an excellent demonstration of how prolonged use of one chord CAN get monotonous. Both Mitchell and Cook find it hard going to maintain interest in the closing bars of their solos. Silver has the pianist's advantage of polyphony - he DOESN'T actually stick to one chord but varies the upper structure. – Laurence Payne Jul 16 '18 at 23:25
3

Listening to that recording what you hear is Horace playing either rhythmic figures constantly or using rhythm to convey information instead of using harmonic invention. This is really hallmark of this specific kind of style - compare with Lee Morgan's Sidewinder or Herbie's (original) Watermelon Man. The Horace recording recording itself features a classic kind of shout chorus, too. To me this is a dead giveaway that the most important ingredient of this tune is the rhythm as opposed to the harmony. So the gist of successfully comping on a tune like this would be to find rhythmic figures that are compelling to play and latch onto rather than harmonic figures. "Dance with the hands like Horace" might be a short way of putting it. But this is all assuming you're trying to play it in a way that reflects the recording - i.e., you're not trying to to a reharm or Snarky-Puppy-ify it.

1

At the very least, assuming it's in key C, I'd be using Dm7 as well as the G7, and probably G9, G11 and G13 too. And even G7+ towards the end of the vamp period.

1

A moving bass line is possible. This can make a nice counter melody to the melody. A scale wise up or down bass doesn't really affect the harmony.

1

When you're comping, you are comp -limenting the music. You do this by focusing on the following elements:

  • Rhythm
  • Voicing
    • Upper structure harmony (9ths, 11ths, 13ths)
    • Inversion

The golden rule of all group improvisation ever is "Yes, and...". Hear what the other musicians are playing and think what would sound good there from your instrument based on the above elements (and anything else you can think of).

It's really no different than regular comping, except that when you're on one chord for a while you need to place more importance on the other elements (rhythm and upper structure harmony for example). Just remember to listen before you play.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.