2

Song link

Numbered musical notation score

Taking this song as example,From the beginning of the song, I was thinking that it must be a Bm, since the songs also end in a Bm. But after looking up the score, it was actually written in D major. So, how do you recognize since the song also starts in Bm (the 6th scale degree of D as you can see in the numbered musical notation). Besides, there's also a #4, which is G#. Is it because of raising the G in B melodic minor? Or it's just little key change to A major? The song also ends in Bm. How can you know the composer's intention whether it's in minor or major since the song could be lingering a lot in minor and occasionally go back to the major key? In short, is it aurally possible to get the "real" key when dealing with such situation?

  • Does Chinese (?) notation distinguish between the major and minor keys that would share the same key signature in Western notation? – Laurence Payne Jul 26 '18 at 10:47
  • Some music is made to not have a tonal center or key too. – marshal craft Jul 26 '18 at 11:05
  • @Laurence the concepts are the same as western music. This is a version of numbered notations score, and the only accurate one, as compared to the original song I used as an example – Yau Qi Herng Jul 26 '18 at 12:22
1

If a piece is written In a particular key, it will have that particular key signature. It can't be helped that every major key has a relative minor, using the exact same notes - sometimes.

Purpose of a key sig. is to avoid having to write in each # or b as it would occur virtually every time - in Bm/D every C# and F# would need putting in with 'accidentals'.

In minor keys, there are sometimes (as hinted earlier) extra notes which need to get changed, and taking Bm, probably more often than not, A# will be found. Some composers in the past (Debussi??) have actually used key sigs that look odd - in Bm for example, F#, C# A#, or bizarrely, in Dm, Bb and C#. Which, in reality wasn't be a bad idea. It just never caught on.

In any written music, listening to it will determine whether it's major or minor (or even modal), but a lot of pieces will sort of modulate in and out of the relatives quite naturally, so it could be said that a piece ostensibly in Bm has passages firmly in D major.

Sadly, the version you post isn't in standard Western manuscript form, and is therefore unintelligible to me, and I suspect, a lot of other posters. But, if the key sig. was indeed F# C#, that would not necessarily denote D major any more than Bm. Last (and often first) notes/harmonies are always a good clue. Bear in mind that with 2#, it could have been in E Dorian...

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.