3

I have read on many many sites that the vocal breaks for the male voice is between E4 and F#4 but in the male vocal groups you have bass singers, baritone singers and tenor singers and their respective tessitura or most comfortable vocal range varies a lot more than just 3 notes. For example. Say I am a bass-baritone, my tessitura will be at least half an octave lower than a tenors tessitura so how can our vocal breaks all be within 3 semitones?

They say the tessitura of a singer is generally below the passagio so if my passagio begins at around Bb or A and a tenors passagio begins half an octave above mine, how can our vocal breaks lie within only 3 semitones apart?

  • Specific to the general position, or lie, of notes in a song - tessitura. Thus a song with quite a few high notes together, although not necessarily out of a reachable range, would be a song with a high tessitura. The word doesn't really apply to a person's singing range. – Tim Jul 26 '18 at 8:38
  • @Tim yes I understand this. I am studying a lot of beatles song and I listen to a lot of J.Lennon parts his main singing range seems to be around C4 - F#4, thereafter Paul would step in on higher parts. For me, I have to lower this by at least 3 full tones for it to sound comfortable. So since my Tessitura would be around 3 tones lower than Johns or perhaps even 4 or 5 tones lower than Pauls, how it ispossible that all our vocal breaks are said to be within 3 semitones. Assuming our tessitura is just below our bridge, my bridge would have to be 6 times as long as those of the tenors – armani Jul 26 '18 at 9:43
  • Problem would be , you, and millions of other singers, don't have a tessitura... Songs do, however. – Tim Jul 26 '18 at 16:03
  • @ Tim according to wikipedia: "Tessitura is the most esthetically acceptable and comfortable vocal range for a given singer." So not sure what you are talking about – armani Jul 27 '18 at 11:07
  • That explanation, I guess, refers to particular songs that have 'the most aesthetically acceptable and comfortable vocal range for a given singer'. It's written ambiguously, more's the pity. And it's not particularly accurate. – Tim Jul 28 '18 at 9:58
0

the vocal breaks for the male voice is between E4 and F#4

This is false for sure. As you said range differences between bass/baritone, and baritone/tenor are in general 2 tones. I believe their breaks will be as much distant from each other.

To refute the statement for good, any tenor can reach chest voice above E4 or F#4. As an example, check this tenor reaching D5 with chest voice. This means the breaking point for tenors is higher than this, and for sure for bass singers it's much lower.

  • Which part of it is false? Also, I am not talking about what notes can be reached, I was talking about tessitura or main singing range. – armani Jul 27 '18 at 11:11
  • @armani this is false: "the vocal breaks for the male voice is between E4 and F#4". And notes that can be reached with chest voice, i. e. without needing transition to head voice, relates a lot with tessitura, tight? – coconochao Jul 27 '18 at 17:01
  • @armani I hope to have clarified my answer with the edits. – coconochao Jul 27 '18 at 17:04
  • 1
    I have done 2 singing programs that say that these are the male vocal breaks. But I won't take any ones word for it just yet :) So according to you, where would you say the male vocal breaks are and also, what is your source for this? – armani Jul 27 '18 at 19:41
  • @armani I don't know and have no source, I can just say that, as you suspected, they are not within 3 semitones, but probably within half an octave. – coconochao Jul 27 '18 at 20:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.