3

Why is it that country musicians who grew up singing in church are often good at singing low notes? What factors would make them sing low notes easily?

Does upbringing determine what vocal range you will end up with or are you just born with a certain range that no southern church can do anything about?

I never hear tenors in country music, more in operas and classical church choirs.

2
  • A cynical answer might be "if somebody can sing high notes well enough to be an operatic tenor, why on earth would they want to sing country music instead?"
    – user19146
    Commented Aug 8, 2018 at 16:50
  • 2
    you got it backwards. people good at low notes are often country singers... Commented Aug 8, 2018 at 18:40

3 Answers 3

6

A singer's range is determined initially by genetics and then by training. There are plenty of tenors who sing country music. You are hearing nothing more than the popularity of lower voices in country music, which causes singers with lower ranges to be able to be more popular than they would in other genres, which often favor higher ranges.

Singing country or church music does not make one's range lower or higher.

1
4

The typical country vocal sound is "intimate", the sound of a close-by utterance. A rumbling voice in its comfort range is one that can retain that impression reasonable well even through a PA while screams and shouts are more of a projecting or traveling sound rather than one that is already close by.

Basically it works pretty well for the kind of sound composition typical for the genre. Country also tends to be more text-heavy than pop or rock, and the text conveys better when close-captioned at comfort pitch and volume than yelled at high pitch.

Good musicians tend to gravitate into genres where their qualities come out best, and country is a genre where a low voice happens to be an asset in the typical genre pieces and instrumental setup.

0

It's from habit that they tend to develop more in the lower range; it could be that they started singing low in church so they didn't attract too much attention to themselves while at church. Nothing like having your parents giving you looks while you are in church.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.