2

I am working on some chord sorting algorithms right now, I was requested to add an algorithm that is capable to sort chords by chord quality, so afaik there are only major, minor, diminished, or augmented chords.

But what happens for example suspended chords?? , they can't be neither major nor minor, so should I have all of the chords that do not are maj, min, dim or aug in a separate pile?, or are there more chords qualities?

Thanks everyone!

  • There are more. This web page is good. edmprod.com/different-chord-types – r lo Nov 10 '18 at 3:59
  • Are you limited to three notes per chord? – Richard Barber Nov 14 '18 at 12:49
  • Ask the requester to provide a list of such "qualities". If they used such a word, then most certainly they can explain what they meant by it? What is the intended purpose of this chord classification? What kind of a person (or another algorithm?) should be able to do what, by utilizing this sorted order? What do you get as input - textual chord names, or note combinations? – piiperi Reinstate Monica Dec 14 '18 at 9:59
0

Here's walkthrough of a calculation of the highest number of chord qualities that you could consider qualities (more on that later). Mathematically, there are a bunch of combinations of intervals that produce chords. There are 12 notes available for the 1st note in the chord, then 11 for the 2nd, then 10, etc. A note any multiple of 12 semitones (an octave) above or below another is the same note and doesn't change chord quality.

12! chord qualities.

However, note that this number is the number of chords that take all 12 chromatic notes. To find all the chords with any number of notes from 1 to 12 inclusive, we need to add in the number of chords with fewer notes. However, once you have that number, you must be careful of enharmonicity. Basically, that's like looking at every note, then considering each note the root, and checking for duplicates. Also, some combinations of intervals form an inversion of another different chord. That's the reason why there's only one chord quality for a 12 note chord (which makes sense, when you think about it).

So, in reality, here's what I can get from intuition (I'm not great at math).

  • 1 12 note chord (like we said)
  • 1 11 note chord (all 12 notes minus one note at any interval to the 1st, but reordering all of them makes them all the same)
  • 1 one note chord (but don't count that, generally a note is not a chord)
  • 11 two note chords (any note plus any other)
  • 110 3 note chords (any note plus any of 11 others plus any of 10 others)

With lots of notes, checking that none of the notes can be considered the root of a different chord quality is extremely difficult. But mathematically, there are hundreds at least. Let me also note that depending on how you limit your horizons of chord qualities, the number of notes is extremely variable. If you consider only diatonic triads to major scales, there are only 3 qualities.

  • 2
    Inversions also drop the number of unique chord qualities substantially. – Dekkadeci Nov 10 '18 at 12:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.