1

Hello I'm workin on a compoute (8,5h) as software developer and start to playing piano, (5 weeks). From time to time a have a slight pull in the wrist.

Should I do some gymnastic, or is this normal at beginning play piano, because there are new positions and movements by the hand? There is no pain or problem by using the thumb.

enter image description here

  • Sounds as though your computer work is the real culprit. If you have pain while playing piano, it’s probably just highlighting and issue you already have caused by computer. There should be no strain when playing piano. Talk to a physical therapist to learn about workplace ergonomics and to get exercises to fix your hand. – jjmusicnotes Dec 5 '18 at 12:38
4

What does "pull" mean?

Are you taking lessons?

You state that you are working as a programmer. I program as well and play guitar. To answer you questions directly:

No, you should not do "gymnastics" that may not help.

Yes, it is sometimes normal to experience discomfort when you start playing a musical instrument because you are using muscles in a way that you have not before. They need time to get used to the new task. Fatigue is normal but pain or numbness and tingling is not normal and an indication that something is wrong.

The reason I ask if you are taking lessons is that a professional pianist will be able to correct bad posture and that could be causing your symptoms. Even thought you are not experiencing pain now you might be stressing your thumb in a way that will cause a more serious problem over time. Also, thumb issues specifically can be a sign of carpel tunnel syndrome which is very common among programmers. I have mild CTS in my right hand and it affects the thumb and first two fingers when it acts up. The pinched nerve makes my hand feel like it's under pressure, it doesn't hurt or tingle. Pinched nerves can often feel like stiffness (sciatica feels like a pulled hamstring). So, in your particular case the adding piano to programming might be pushing your hands over the edge. If you are older it could be a sign of arthritis. Almost all of us will get it at some point.

People on this site cannot and will not give medical advise and even if we could (there are probably doctor-musicians here) it would be impossible to tell based on your question. You should see a doctor about the thumb regardless of your piano playing as your computer work may be causing CTS.

Then, take lessons.

  • thank you for your very exhaustive description.... if it does not get better during the text two week, I'll visit my doctor, so far a I know his son plays piano too. :) – michael-mammut Dec 5 '18 at 14:16
  • yeah, don't worry. Could be nothing. I have mild CTS and it's very manageable. The computer is the cause and guitar playing actually makes it feel better. I wear a brace when I type and it goes away. – ggcg Dec 6 '18 at 5:02
  • No problem, I'm playing guitare to an there is all right :). I belive, a good question is to get a piano teacher for "check-session" and small exercise units. than it should work. – michael-mammut Dec 6 '18 at 8:34

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.