2

Is it advisable for a beginner to wear finger guard when playing the guitar or ukulele? Picture of Finger Guard for guitars

Picture taken from Google Images

  • 2
    Please don't try to learn how to play with those; they look only a little better than trying to learn to play while wearing mittens. – David Bowling Dec 9 '18 at 5:08
  • 1
    This looks like a bad idea all around. Reminds me of the spring loaded finger machines that were popular in the 80s. People thought it would make their grip stringer. Maybe it does but you don't need a string grip to play guitar. Seems like the product is a red herring. Just play and your fingers will adjust, that is necessary to get good and I think you will delay that process. – ggcg Dec 9 '18 at 11:58
6

I would say no. Getting your fingers conditioned to playing is a necessary step. Unless you have some unique medical necessity, just play a little each day, and when your fingers get tired take a break. After a few weeks will find you will be able to play for longer periods without it feeling like the guitar hates your fingers.

  • commenting on my own answer here: just started playing bass and my plucking hand is NOT used to plucking the bass (i am a guitarist so no issue with the fretting hand) and i find that i want to play more than my fingers want me to play. in that case i just use a pick so i can play a little more and not develop (or make worse) any blisters. the first few days i played i played until my finger had a blister which caused a big cut and i had to stop playing. now i will play until i feel like it is becoming a problem and then use a pick. once my fingers are conditioned i will stop doing this. – b3ko Feb 12 at 20:13
4

Guessing it's either on your fretting fingers, or plucking fingers. Neither should be necessary. If it's a well set up guitar, and the strings are not too heavy, making them very difficult to press down. there won't be a problem there. Some will say you'll develop callouses - very hard skin - on fingertips. In the last 50 yrs or so, I've never had them. Maybe it's me, and the way the guitars/basses are set up.

If it's for the plucking fingers, again, no, as you use the finger pads and/or the fingernails and anything worn on fingers/thumb will be detrimental. If you want to strum, use a pick. If you want to pick, slip-on finger picks are available.

When you play, and you reach the point when your fingers ache or hurt, it's just God's way of saying 'have a rest'!

4

This may be more of the same, but here is my 2 cents.

I cannot tell what the purpose of the device is. Ideally you want to develop a haptic connection with your instrument so it becomes an extension of yourself. That being said my first reaction to these devices is that you will NEVER develop the right feeling using these things. But then I am reminded of Tony Iommi of Black Sabbath who lost the ends of two of his fretting hand fingers early in his life in a work related accident. He has prosthetic ends made of wood and leather. So he cannot feel the tip touch the string but over time I would guess that he developed sensitivity of the wood touching the end of whatever skin is touching it. That would evolve into a true haptic connection.

I can only imagine that these little devices "protect" you skin from getting sore when you play. The problem with that is that you need to evolve past that to develop real chops with both hands. If you are using these to allow yourself to play past an amount of time where you would feel your fingers getting bruised then I would say your actions are self defeating. Here is why I think that. Presumably, in time, you will take them off. When you do this you will essentially be starting over and need to develop that haptic connection from scratch. This happens to experienced player if they decide to change technique. The evolution time is usually not as bad as starting over but can take several months is the change is drastic. You are setting yourself up to not learn. If, on the other hand, you intend to uses these forever I see no reason why you cannot develop a good tone and technique but now these pads will need to be part of your playing to get the feel you are used to.

In general I think devices like this are a marketing gimmick and serve no real purpose to beginners. Similar gimmicks that have misleading arguments for use in guitar playing are (1) the spring loaded grip developer, and (2) the guitar with LED lights on the finger board to light up the correct spots to finger in any key or mode. Neither of these helps in the learning process and can have negative effects over time.

  • 1
    Prefer this one over Tim's answer because of a sentence hidden in the middle of the 2nd paragraph: ".. Presumably, in time, you will take them off. When you do this you will essentially be starting over..." – Willem van Rumpt Dec 10 '18 at 15:43
1

Considering that your image is of an ukulele, let me share some of the ukulele playing perspective.

Generally, finger guards on the strumming hand of the ukulele is not really advised. You could, for sure, but I don't think you'll need them. If I may guess, I think that probably after playing a little while, the strings start to feel as though they are cutting your fingers or making them raw. I think that if your fingers start to hurt, the best way to handle it would be to stop and let your fingers heal. Eventually (for me this started to happen within 2 months of starting playing), I stopped feeling any pain. Especially on ukulele, with non-metal strings, finger guards shouldn't be necessary. If you want to use them, you can, but here are a few pros and cons:

Pros:

  • One's fingertips are protected from the pain
  • Possibly a better grip on the strings
  • Maybe a cleaner tone(?)
  • Vibrato and natural harmonics might be easier
  • Playing with a slide is impossible
  • If you have medical complications from this, the of course this will solve your problem

Cons:

  • Finger guards don't protect the rest of the finger, so barre chords will still be in contact with the skin
  • Slides might be affected/harder
  • Vibrato might be harder, and the possible benefit of natural harmonics won't apply to artificial harmonics
  • Your fingers will effectively be larger, making cramped positions more difficult
  • It's an additional cost, as well as they will break over use/time
  • People will think you're weird (that's their fault, but still)
  • Pull-offs might accidentally pull the entire guard off of your finger

As for guards on the picking hand:

Let me just say that I learned to strum with the nail and skin of my index finger, which did start to hurt when I first started to play. After a few months, though, it stopped being a problem. I'd say if it hurts and you're not bleeding, you just stop playing. If you're bleeding, you're playing too hard or too much or something. That aside, there are other better options, for example thumb strumming or using more than one finger, or of course fingerpicking. Here are some pros and cons of guards on the picking hand:

Pros:

  • Artificial harmonics also get easier
  • Less strumming pain
  • Better grip on the strings if fingerpicking
  • It will allow you to play much more forcefully, as it won't hurt to play louder

Cons:

  • You might even need one on the thumb, because thumbs are a big part of strumming
  • One can never vary their tone by using nails, because the nails never touch the strings
  • Different tone when strumming

If you start with guards, you're either going to have to eventually learn to play without them, in which case it's better to learn that now, or you'll use guards forever, which might be fine, depending on what you decide. It's your choice, but I can't say that they are necessary, as most ukulele players never use these. Also consider that guitarists and bassists also never usually use these, and they have to deal with metal strings and much thicker strings. String instruments also don't use these, and I can't think of any instrument that does use them.

  • 2
    None of those "pros" make sense. – ggcg Dec 9 '18 at 11:56
  • @ggcg Do you have any good pros I could use? Or would you simply argue that ther are no advantages? – user45266 Dec 9 '18 at 23:40
  • With all due respect I do not see any pros. Please see my answer for details. – ggcg Dec 10 '18 at 0:00
  • Okay, some of my claims are a little sketchy there, but I do believe that maybe they could be used for some novelty effect or something. I do agree that generally these sorts of devices are often made out to be much more useful than they really are, and I agree with your answer. – user45266 Dec 10 '18 at 0:09
0

if your fingers hurt use smaller string size

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.