4

I would greatly appreciate it if someone could help me. Currently, I am learning about Authentic, Half, and Plagal Cadences. And I have to find them in composition, then tell the name. At first it seemed rather easy, but now I'm stuck. I found the root position, but the inversion it shows is not possible! I am so confused!

enter image description here

5

Assuming the tonic is F, this does appear to be a V6–I progression, which likely doesn't match your definition of V–I necessary for an authentic cadence.

It's possible that the person that gave this example is viewing that final sixteenth-note C as creating a bona fide root-position V, but that seems strange to me. Most people would view the C as an inner voice and the E as the "real" bass pitch, keeping this as a V6.

There are all kinds of different definitions for cadences; some textbooks would consider this an imperfect authentic cadence, since the V is in inversion. (I personally disagree with this assessment, but it's ultimately up to the textbook that you chose.)

Another possibility is the notion of a "contrapuntal cadence." In contrapuntal cadences, the V and/or I are in inversion. As such, they show a clear progression from V to I without the harmonic articulation of an authentic cadence. V6–I, since the V is in inversion, would be considered a contrapuntal cadence.

1

1))The first circled chord contains the notes CEG.

2))The next chord has F and A.

What is in the key signature for this example? Is it a B Flat? If so, you're likely in F Major.

So the second chord would be the I chord in F Major.

If you travel up the F Major scale-- F G A Bb C, C is the fifth scale degree and the place where the CEG chord is built.

What you are looking at is a V - I Cadence.

Therefore it is an authentic cadence!

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.