2

I understand that this may be basic. I have a chorus progression (C major) I am working on, and it originally started as basically the following:

I-VII-V-vi-V

I wanted to experiment a little by added notes outside of the triad. Then I thought I would just hold the G and C notes from the I chord throughout the rest of the progression. I like the effect, but I need to know more specifically what exactly I did and how dramatically I altered the chords. Here's how it looks now:

enter image description here

Can you help me identify the new chords? This leads to a broader question I have been curious about. When you add a seventh, say, to a V chord, you get a V7. When you add a sixth to a V chord, you get a V6. But what about when you add a sixth and a seventh? Or a sixth, a seventh, and a fourth? Is it a game of "majority rules" regarding how to name the chord? Does the root note carry more importance than other notes?

I would be very appreciative if you could help me get to the bottom of this! Thanks!

-286642

3

I would analyze this a bit differently:

Keep in mind that not every pitch you play has to be a chord tone. Some pitches are what we call non-chord tones, meaning they are lower in the hierarchy and don't affect our understanding of a given harmony.

One such non-chord tone is the pedal (or pedal point), where a pitch just holds through without changing. And this is exactly what you have here: After your I chord in m. 1, the C G both stay as pedal points as you move into VII.

But you're right, when you add a sixth and a seventh, you start to create a bit of a cluster chord; sometimes it's best to go with Occam's razor and find the more basic solution. Your last measure, for instance, might best be understood as a Gsus4 (there's actually not an add6, because there's no E). Similarly, your V? might best be viewed as a C/G chord with a D non-chord tone; but others would be comfortable calling that a Gsus4add6.

This process is a balancing act: sometimes the more advanced chord will tell you what's happening in the music more clearly. But other times, multiple chord names will get the job done. I'm not sure there's a hard and fast rule, unfortunately.

  • this is very helpful @richard! thank you! – 286642 Jan 15 at 2:29

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.