1

When transposing, if its transpose down a Major 6th from C. Do you take the key of Eb and say that a major 6th up is C as that would be a major 6th down. But cause your starting note is C if you took the key of C major it would be E natural?

  • I need to know which note I class as my starting note even though I am transposing down. – Ethan Jarrott Jan 18 at 15:26
1

It's simple to use the lower note as the base (yes, base) note when calculating intervals. E♭ to C is the major 6th interval, so, yes, 'going down a maj 6th' would put the transposed key to E♭. Since C>E is a M3, the inverse (E>C) is a m6.

1

a major 6th down is a major 6th down, what ever the key will be.

0

Yes, Eb is correct. I'll offer another way to think about it: change the interval to half steps. Since a major 6th is 9 half steps no matter what key you're in, transposing down a major 6th means transposing down 9 half steps. It doesn't matter that the Eb is a minor key in C ... you're not in C anymore. C has gone from the tonic to the major 6th of Eb. Same pitch, different context.

My rule of thumb in general, however, is not to go over 6 half steps. So with your assignment, I'd actually invert and think about it as composing up a minor 3rd, which is 3 half steps and the exact same thing. (NOTE: this would be an octave higher of course, so this rule of thumb only applies when octave doesn't matter, such as transposing chord progressions. If you're doing a melody, the octave matters very much.)

  • 1
    Could be in trouble with this method. Each and every interval has at least two names, giving a choice of note names. Eb>C is M6, whereas D#>C is diminished 7th. Counting semitones could end up as Eb, but could also be D#, a different written key altogether.Wrong answer in an exam! And what does 'Eb is a minor key in C' mean? – Tim Jan 19 at 6:15
  • Well it wasn't really an exam answer, it was a way to think about it. Be it Eb or D#, M6 or dim7, the distance from C is still 9 half steps. – DriveItLikeYouStoleIt Jan 21 at 0:28
  • 'Eb is a minor key in C' was meant to address the last sentence in OP, pointing out that Eb isn't in the key of C major - OP said it would actually be E natural. If you're thinking in the key of C, Eb is minor tone, not a major 6th it anything else. – DriveItLikeYouStoleIt Jan 21 at 0:34

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.