I was looking at Itzhak Perlman playing Shalom Aleichem It starts (0:14) in E Phrygian Dominant with the i chord, but ends (4:16) in A minor, the iv chord.

I've seen the same thing happen with Hava Nagila where they play it in D phrygian, starts (0:28) with i chord, but ends on iv chord, G minor (2:31). did it modulate?


Actually, the Perlman piece begins with the tonic chord of A minor; the entire piece begins and ends in A.

This piece uses A harmonic minor, it's just that that collection is equivalent to the E Phrygian dominant collection; the only difference is which pitch is tonic.

With that said, it is possible for a piece to begin in a key and ultimately modulate to its subdominant—this does happen in "Hava Nagila." In such cases, we often understand the opening of the piece as conceptually being a large dominant to the final tonic. In other words, the opening D, with a close in G, is just a big V–i (D–G) motion in G minor.

  • 1
    @foreyez I hear D as the opening tonic of "Hava Nagila," but it ends in G. The Perlman, however, definitely begins in A. The melody might begin on E, but that's definitely within an A-minor context. – Richard Jan 19 at 19:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.