2

I have a question with probably not such a straightforward answer, but I'd love some guidance.

I'm 25 years old, and I started learning the piano when I was 11 years old. After 5 years of learning I quit taking music classes, which I actually regretted doing, so about two years ago I bought myself a piano and started practicing again on my own, and this year (from september on) I have started taking piano classes again.

I progressed quite fast when I was younger I'd say, and I feel right now the same is happening. I'm quite dedicated and practice every day, I don't have a rigorous planning but I think I do atleast half an hour per day.

And now to come to my actual question: I have actually always thought about learning the violin besides piano because I find it such a beautiful instrument, and recently I've been thinking I'm in a good place right now to start learning it. The one thing that scares me is the idea that it would take me years to learn just the absolute basics (just producing clean notes, lets say). So I was wondering how long it usually takes to get past the first stage of learning the violin where it sounds just horrible (lets be honest), keeping my experience in mind. By the way, I would definitely take classes for it if I would start playing.

Thanks in advance!

1

"The one thing that scares me is the idea that it would take me years to learn just the absolute basics"

This is more of a psychological issue than a musical issue. I'll share some of my experiences and maybe that will help. I started on the violin at age 5. I was good right away and excelled fast in private lessons. At about 8 or 9 (I don't remember) I started private lessons on electric guitar and forgot about the violin. Later in high school I wanted to enter an accelerated music program at a college prep academy and guitar was not on the list of allowed instruments. So I thought I'll just pick up the violin again and it will be no problem to get my chops back. That never happened. It was a disaster. I started on the upright bass and took to that so fast I was doing gigs within 6 months. However! I continued with classical bass lessons for about 6 years and personally feel like I never mastered the bow (regardless of whether my instructor gave positive feedback), but I persisted. I tried different quality of bow, weights on the bow etc. As a music major I had to "learn" piano (take piano lab) and hated it. I have no problem using both hands on the classical guitar but could never coordinate both on the piano (I will likely never understand why). At this point in my life I've played guitar professionally for many years and decided last year to take classical voice lessons. I have gotten better but it was a real crush to my ego that I didn't take to it naturally, as with guitar and bass. But it is what it is.

If you're looking for someone to tell you that violin is easy or not that is not a fair question since it depends on the person. For me it was easy then impossible as I was a different person 5 years after quitting. I will tell you a couple things about any member of this family of instruments.

(1) They are fretless. Unlike the piano which is an equal tempered instrument the violin, cello, and bass are fretless so there is no guide for being in tune except the ear. You will need to get used to that and that is good for all musicians in my opinion.

(2) The bow can be a challenge to master for some. But that depends on the quality of the bow and the teacher.

I think you should get a teacher from the start if you want to seriously explore the violin. Also, you are going to just have to try and see how it goes. So what if it takes 5 years to get good? That is what it takes. You are either committed or not. If you put a time constraint on it before you start you have already quit. I'd say just try and see if you like it. See if it fits your body and personality. Then you will devote the time and the technique will evolve.

I think that most people that pursue the arts have some natural talent in one area or another. This is good but can backfire in that when things take actual effort it's a turn off. The things that take effort are definitely worth doing.

0

Well, you practice for about at least 30 minutes a day on piano, so if you're willing to do the same on the violin, I'm pretty sure you can learn it. It probably won't take you too long to get past the basics, considering that you practice every day. You might want to ask your violin teacher (if you get one) about that because it really depends for everybody. For some people, it might take a few years, but for others, it might take only a few months. Some tips...

  1. Listen to the violin. A LOT. When you listen to it, you can try to find the beat or maybe just listen to it for fun. It might speed up the process from the "beginner stage". Whatever book you are using (I use Suzuki), listen to the soundtracks. That'll probably make the process faster.
  2. Ask questions. Since you said that you'll get a teacher, I agree with @ggcg on getting a teacher at the start if you're serious about learning about it. If you're confused, don't be afraid to ask questions. (You can ask questions on here and to your teacher)

You probably will have tapes on your violin as guidance as to where your fingers go. Gradually, as you get better at it, the tapes might be removed from you violin. And also, don't be nervous! You'll be just fine. You should probably talk to your teacher about it.

I hope you decide to take on learning the violin!

~ CatbusTotoroDustbunnies07

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.