4

This question already has an answer here:

I replaced one nylon string (the G string) with a steel string. All the other strings are nylon. Is this okay?

marked as duplicate by Dom Feb 13 at 15:26

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

6

The short answer is no. The tension of steel strings are way to much for a classical guitar to handle as it generally does not have a truss rod in the neck.

5

You'll probably get away with it on a temporary basis, but the tension isn't good for that guitar. Certainly, on a classical guitar, I wouldn't be putting all 6 on. One won't be too detrimental, but also the feel will be different - tighter, thinner - and certainly the sound will be different, so it's inappropriate for many reasons.

0

Steel strings are available in a wide range of gauges, which will need different levels of tension to play at any given pitch. For the most part, one may reduce the tension required to play a certain pitch by using a narrower string, but as metal strings get too loose, pitch stability suffers severely--much more so than with nylon strings.

The tension on a 13-gauge steel string (the "e'" from an heavy-gauge set or a "b" from a lighter set) would be about 9.7lbs. That's rather light as steel strings go, but probably not unplayable, and it should be safe on a nylon-string guitar (many nylon sets average slightly over 10lbs). I would not expect such a string to sound very good or offer a good playing experience when used in that fashion, but the tension should be low enough to avoid damaging anything. Using a 14 gauge string would increase tension to about 11.2lbs; that would probably improve playability, and would probably be safe, but would leave less safety margin against accidental over-tightening.

  • I've used .008" top, .010" second for the last 40+yrs, with no pitch problems – Tim Feb 12 at 19:56
  • @Tim: A 13ga "g" string would fit right in with a set of 8's for an electric. Some people like 8's, and on a guitar with a suitable action height they can work just fine. Nylon guitars often have higher actions, however, and I would expect that a 13ga "g" would be right on the cusp of usability--much better than a 12ga, but noticeably worse than a 14ga. – supercat Feb 13 at 16:28
0

Replacing one string with a steel one won't damage the guitar, but the playability of the guitar won't be good. Drive down to a local guitar store and buy a nylon replacement (or even a new full set).

0

(I'm sure I answered this before...)

Hey, it's your instrument; the guitar police won't break down your door for putting that string on your instrument. And it isn't like diesel in a gas engine; the damage won't be immediate and cause complete failure. The instrument will be playable until it won't.

But that's not what it's built for, and strings are cheap.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.