1

enter image description here This is my first phrase in my scherzo. The eighth notes in the right hand and the focus on Bb at first, making it sound like it is in Bb major instead of F major, despite the E naturals makes the right hand, I think sound like a true scherzo, at least until the cadence lands on F. The left hand however, I think diminishes the scherzo quality because it is a simple quarter note bass line until the cadence is reached and there are 2 dotted quarters.

I am writing this scherzo as an isolated scherzo as you can probably tell from the title in the image being Scherzo in F. So how do I put the joke into the music? If you can't tell already, I kind of going with a Haydnesque approach to this scherzo, in other words, really making it sound like a joke instead of one of Beethoven's more serious sounding scherzos.

I mean, just listen to this Haydn Scherzo:

and compare it to this Beethoven Scherzo:

The Beethoven scherzo, even though this is from one of his early works,sounds much more serious with both the parallel and relative minors appearing. Neither of these appear in the Haydn scherzo, the Haydn scherzo is exclusively major with no appearance of the minor as a key. My scherzo so far is similar to the Haydn scherzo in personality(doesn't sound too serious, unlike the Beethoven scherzo).

But how do I put the joke into the music as I write the scherzo? I don't really have a sense of humor so that wouldn't help. Would I like do everything to make you expect an F major harmony to come next but instead have D minor harmony appear(in other words, evading the cadence via deceptive resolution) or what? And I want to keep the light Haydnesque feel of the scherzo.

closed as unclear what you're asking by user45266, Todd Wilcox, Carl Witthoft, Doktor Mayhem Feb 25 at 23:04

Please clarify your specific problem or add additional details to highlight exactly what you need. As it's currently written, it’s hard to tell exactly what you're asking. See the How to Ask page for help clarifying this question. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 2
    Unusual notes in bar 7. Looks like 6/8 time. – Tim Feb 25 at 6:40
  • How is 6 eighth notes in a 3/4 measure unusual? – Caters Feb 25 at 6:45
  • 3/4 is usually written as three separate beats, but the software has decided to make it look like 6/8 (two lots of 3 quavers), rather than tie notes. – Tim Feb 25 at 6:50
  • I don't see that. I see 3 lots of 2 eighth notes. And don't the 3 quarter notes in the left hand make it clear that it is 3/4 and not 6/8 since in 6/8, 1 quarter note is like 2 notes of an eighth note triplet in 2/4, and not really 2 regular eighth notes in terms of how the note length relates to the beat? – Caters Feb 25 at 6:58
  • 4
    In the first 6 bars, yes. All I'm saying is bar 7 would more normally be written crotchet-tied-to quaver, then quaver-tied-to-crotchet. Slightly easier to read, and more conventional. – Tim Feb 25 at 7:05

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.