3

I practice with 3 different Euphoniums, a brass-instrument like a small tuba. One of them - a Yamaha training instrument with 4 valves in a row - has a bad intonation at the natural fifth (upper G) actually the f ... which can hardly be compensated by lip tension or embouchure. I have no idea what could be the reason of this phenomenon as this tone is part of the overtone series.

1

A perfect air column contained in a perfect, straight tube, plays the notes of the harmonic series.

A real-world instrument, with all its twists, bends and constrictions, doesn't.

Part of the art of designing a good instrument is minimising these imperfections. Or the designer may have taken the attitude 'Ok the open note is out of tune, but it's fine with an alternate fingering'. Try 1+3 or 4.

(I think that's right. We're talking in 'Bb transposed' notation? Anyway, try SOME alternative fingering.)

You think THAT's bad? Look at the overtone series of a church bell. It bears very little resemblence to the theoretical harmonic series. It isn't a simple tuning fork, designed for purity of pitch, it's a very complex resonant system. The 'hum note' may be a major 7th below the 'strike note'! This isn't the place to discuss it fully, just know that real instruments don't have a nice tidy overtone structure!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strike_tone

  • Yes, I‘m talking about Bb instrument. My question is concerning the fifth and I can‘t understand that it sound so much wrong as it doesn‘t need any walve and no compenation. And with all other instruments I never had this problem. I could even post a piece of the Tokyo Staff Band where you can hear the same negative effect. – Albrecht Hügli Mar 3 at 15:08
  • 2
    Read my answer again. A euphonium is not a laboratory demonstration of acoustical principles, it's an imperfect, real-world object. – Laurence Payne Mar 3 at 15:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.