So I started learning music theory this January 2019, I've learned very quickly from basic to advanced because I've been playing guitar (self-taught) for 9 years...

I can now identify any interval by ear very easily... I can also sing the first pitch of any song in my head and it is mostly right (if it is wrong then it is a semitone higher or lower)... I can also think of the note C and sing it but I most of the time sing it a bit sharp (to be exact 40 cents sharper than actual C) so it is about a quarter tone sharper.

I keep listening to C for a long to fix my intonation but then if I stay hours without music and then sing it, I always sing it 40 cents higher... it is the same for other notes sometimes.

I can also sing any note without any reference just by thinking of it in my head. Do I have perfect pitch or do I just have a relative pitch with a good pitch memory?...

...Or maybe I had it and I didn't know before? So now I'm getting it back with practice?


I would say that you definitely have perfect pitch, since you can at least identify a C within 40 cents. That means you can still "round it" to the nearest semitone. I think from general usage, if you can at least distinguish one semitone from another, you'll have perfect pitch, not relative pitch.

For this answer I did some Googling, and found a study where a person who has perfect pitch was asked whether he can notice detuning at the end of a music performance. The music started at the right pitch, but slowly detuning at the rate of 2 cents per minute, until at the end the music was detuned by 33 cents. He could NOT notice it ! https://news.uchicago.edu/story/perfect-pitch-may-not-be-absolute-after-all

You bring a good point about good pitch memory being different than perfect pitch. I don' know whether in general usage it matters. But I DO sometimes resort to pitch memory if the sound is not keyboard instrument (I'm a trained classical pianist and organist), such as vocal music. When I'm not sure, I resort to my memory of a piano piece I practiced a LOT in college: J.S. Bach Italian concerto (in F Major). By remembering the piano sound of the first few measures, I found that I can reliably produce F1 within 20 cents accuracy. With this F as my "tuning fork" I can then produce other notes.

So my suggestion for improvement is to pick a piece that you really enjoy and practice the piece a lot with a perfectly tuned guitar. Hopefully overtime the neurons in your brain can record some measures of the piece. Then try to recall the whole measures as a "hint" to get at one note you'll use as reference. Maybe that way your sharp bias can be corrected.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.