2

Please confirm if it is possible to play D scale tune on A scale Bansuri, i.e convert

Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Dha Ni

to

Ma Pa Dha Ni Sa Re Ga

According to this, it will work for Chinese bamboo flute, Playing Chinese bamboo flute of key "D" as "C"?

For instance, if D scale of O RE PIYA is

P...M(T)DPM(T)G...R...M(T)G...
GM(T) PD...PM(T)
M(T)DPM(T)PDN....G...N

would get moved up 3 notes on A Bansuri, i.e.

S...N(T)RSN(T)D...P...N(T)D...
DN(T) SR...SN(T)
N(T)RSN(T)SRG....D...G

1

Shifting the scale like this won't really work on a Bansuri, and even more generally for a composition that is raga based. This is because the relative pitches of successive notes are not the same, or in other words Indian classical music does not use an equal tempered scale.

You could try shifting the notes and playing the song, but it will sound slightly out of tune to a trained ear.


(My expertise does not lie in Western classical music, so if I am using the terminology "equal temperament" incorrectly, then I would be happy to be corrected by someone knowledgeable on these matters.)

  • 1
    equal tempered scale Wow that is an excellent point. I tried playing straight D, then I tried shifting for A-scale Bansuri .... I guess I didn't notice the difference since I still need lot of practice with speed, and making half note. – Marium Apr 22 at 16:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.