'A pirate's life for me' sounds like it's in A minor (and that's what multiple websites indicate) yet there's an A#/Bb in it. Where does that Bb come from? Does it modulate between F major and A minor somehow? It doesn't seem to resolve and the modulation sounds almost flawless. What's going on?

  • 1
    To me, the more interesting question is whether it's in F major or D minor. Perhaps the "A minor" label by the website is the result of the G chords (and therefore B♮) that are secondary dominants of the V, C major, which is enharmonic as a key signature, to A minor? Either way, I suspect one website made a mistake and others copied it. Definitely more F major than A minor. – user45266 May 6 at 2:19
  • @user45266 yeah maybe not A minor, it's just when I heard the song it had a distinctive mysterious minor quality to it. and when I looked it up on those websites it said "A minor" so I got confused. It doesn't sound completely major to me. There's something fishy going on with this song. – foreyez May 6 at 3:58
  • 2
    Starting and finishing on F major, how can it 'sound like it's in A minor'? Said it too many times - just because it's on the 'net doesn't give it any more credence than if it was 'heard in the playground'. – Tim May 6 at 7:12

To me, the piece does not sound like being in A minor in any way. The websites linked do not look trustworthy, especially considering that notediscover.com claims "A minor" but actually shows the key signature of A major.

The first thing you should look at to determine the key of a piece is the final chord, which is obviously F major. The next thing you might look at is the chord the phrases end with:

  • at 0:08, the first phrase ends on F (just F, but from the notes used before, it's clearly F major).
  • at 0:12, the second phrase indeed ends on A minor, so there is an A minor chord in this piece, but it doesn't mean the key has to be A minor. A minor is a chord that is available from the notes in the F major scale.
  • at 0:16, the third phrase ends on C major, and to me it is used clearly in a dominant function (it doesn't sound like the piece may end here, it sounds like the music must go on), so we are still in F major.
  • up to 0:30: The fourth to sixth phrase are a repetition of the first three phrases.
  • up to 0:42: A variation of the first three phrases, still the same chords
  • up to 0:50: Another variation on the second and third phrase
  • up to 1:03: Again the main three phrases, still (F (major), A minor, C major)
  • up to 1:07: Now it gets interesting! It sounds like the first phrase again, but it ends with G as bass note, and the melody notes build a G7 chord on top (5th missing), but a natural B instead of B-flat. This might be the onset of a modulation (Let's guess: to C major)
  • up to 1:11: Another phrase ending on G major.
  • up to 1:15: This phrase ends on C major. This time, it sounds like the the tonic, not like a chord that leads toward F major. To me, this is a convincing modulation, and the guess seems right.
  • up to 1:21: This phrase ends on D major. With F# in the final chord of phrase, this is definitely no longer F major. Maybe the piece is trying to do next step in the circle of fifths to modulate to G major?
  • up to 1:24: Indeed, this phrase ends on G major, and D major was used as dominant of G major. I would call this second modulation.
  • up to 1:28: Out of a sudden, the F# and B natural are gone, but we get to see a Eb instead. The phrase ends on g minor. I interpret this as continuing to modulate.
  • up to 1:32: This phrase ends on Bb major, the parallel key to g minor. The g minor chord was just an intermediate step to get to Bb major.
  • up to 1:37: This phrase ends on Eb major.
  • up to 1:41: This phrase ends on C minor.
  • up to 1:45: This phrase ends on E minor.
  • up to 1:49: This phrase ends on F major (back home?).
  • up to 1:54: This phrase ends on C major (used as dominant of F major again)
  • up to 1:58: This phrase ends on F major, definitely the tonic here, so the piece modulated back to F major
  • up to 2:02: This phrase ends on D minor, the parallel key to F major.
  • up to 2:06: This phrase ends on C major, the dominant of F major.
  • up to 2:11: This phrase ends on D minor, a variation of the phrase up to 2:02.
  • up to 2:17: This phrase ends on F major.

So in this piece, the main key is fore sure F major, starting with a I-iii-V progression, followed by modulation to C major, G major, Bb major, some further key changes that change so quickly that for my listening experience, no new key is established until it gets back to F major again. The piece definetely does not modulate to A minor anywhere, as the dominant E major does not appear to establish A minor as key.

The last four phrases match the well-known western form of a period, in that it contains of two similar parts, the first one ending on the dominant chord while the second parts sounds similar to the first part, but ends in the tonic.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.