0

I just watched youtube videos where he found the music melody notes + chords then he said that it's better if we play the song on Am instead (originally the song play on f#m). He gave the new melody notes + chords, the notes and chords changed. How to know what/where melody notes to play? I mean everytime i arranging, i just trying out every line in first 4 fret and playing the bass of the chords i found at internet. There are many version at internet of the song (one playing in C, other sites playing at G chord) i dont know which chord fit with melody notes that i found.

closed as unclear what you're asking by Todd Wilcox, topo morto, Peter, Richard, Tim Jun 24 at 7:05

Please clarify your specific problem or add additional details to highlight exactly what you need. As it's currently written, it’s hard to tell exactly what you're asking. See the How to Ask page for help clarifying this question. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 1
    It's a bit difficult to understand exactly what you mean in this question. Could you tell us more, please? – Tim Jun 23 at 9:45
  • 1. Let say i found the melody notes in the first four fret, how to know which chord should i play along the notes, in the internet there 2 version chords of the song, one played in C chord and the other in G chords – Frds Jun 23 at 9:48
  • 1
    The problem is - we can find all the notes in just about every key, on those first four frets! and the other problem is, there is a lot of wrong stuff on the 'net. – Tim Jun 23 at 10:00
  • 2
    can you add a link to the particular youtube video, and the time that you mean? – topo morto Jun 23 at 12:35
0

Melodies don't "fit" chords.

Melody - the horizontal, linear aspect of music - simultaneously provides tones that provide part of the chords of the harmony and notes that are not part of the chords. We can refer to chord tones and non-chord tones, and that sense the chord tones are the ones that "fit" the chords.

Some melodies are all chord tones, like Amazing Grace...

enter image description here

Other melodies use non-chord tones emphatically...

enter image description here

...notice that the first notes of bars 2 and 3 are non-chord tones.

The tricky part is this: conceptually the chord proper is perceived even when non-chord tones are used. So, in bar two of Moon River the chord is Am even a beat 1 despite the melody playing the non-chord tone D.

To demonstrate this point omit the melody part from the accompaniment: omit the G from the C chords and the C from Am and the A from F7. When you do that you should hear the chords clearly on beat 1 of each bar. Again those chords are clear despite the non-chord tones.

Now it should be clearer that melodies don't "fit" chords, but are a contributing part of the harmony. The harmony is generated primarily from the bass and the melody harmonizes with the bass using an interplay of chord and non-chord tones.

Now back to the question of how to harmonize a melody: you don't "fit" the melody to chord tones, you provide a harmonic setting for the melody. Make sure the bass and harmony are good, and consider whether any given melody note should be treated as a chord tone or non-chord tone.

0

There are 2 fundamental different approaches of learning songs:

  1. Starting with simple songs (e.g. children and baby songs, folk songs etc. only 2 chords), going on, stage and sequence, discovering that these little tunes are elements of more complicated songs.

  2. Learning a song or a piece on a higher level, having a fix idea what you want to learn (für Elise, Moonshine Sonate, or the Piano Concerto in b minor by Tschaikovsky ...) and being fully motivated but often disappointed, when you see it’s a long way and hard work.

So to answer your question:

Why not taking a basic workshop and progressing step by step? There are lots of videos and tutorials. And later you will find out which chords are fitting to which melody.

  • I like 'Moonshine Sonata'. Was Ludwig an alcoholic? – Tim Jun 23 at 17:46

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.