2

I am studying a miniature score of Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring (Dover Miniature Scores). For the clarinets, I see this in the instrumentation page:

Clarinetto piccolo (D, Es)

3 Clarinetti (B, A) (Cl. II = Cl. b. II)

Clarinetto basso (B) (= Cl. IV)

This appears to be Italian but with German notes.

Alongside, there is the English:

Small Clarinet (D, E♭)

3 Clarinets (B♭, A)(Cl. II = Bass Cl.II)

Bass Clarinet (B♭) (= Cl. IV)

So, we need 5 players but the number of instruments is less clear. Using some invented names to make discussion easier.

Alice plays the small clarinets. She needs a D and an E♭.

Bob plays only a standard clarinet. He needs an A and B♭.

Carol mostly plays a standard clarinet but may be required to play a second bass. She needs an A, B♭ and a bass.

David, like Bob, plays only a standard clarinet. He needs an A and B♭.

Elizabeth mostly pass the bass but may be called on to play 4th regular clarinet. She needs a bass and one or both of an A and B♭.

It is Elizabeth's role that is least clear to me.

If I am correct, between them, there are:

1 D

1 E♭

3 or 4 A

3 or 4 B♭

2 bass

So, 10, 11, or 12 depending on the interpretation of Elizabeth's role.

I will examine the score in more detail later to try to find more clues.

Note that this question was originally combined with one on the bass clarinet notation. I have split them.

  • 2
    I just scanned a score (in a PDF on my phone, so not very carefully) and I think I saw that there is inconsistency about bass clarinet II, which is sometimes played by Cl. II and sometimes by Cl. III. It also looks like there are never three A clarinets. It does indeed seem that (as asserted in a comment on the related question) bass clarinet I never plays anything else. So it could be that 9 instruments are possible. Thanks for picking up on my abortive attempt at naming the players :-) – phoog Jul 7 at 14:16
2

The instrumentation page in the Dover score is incorrect. If you closely look at the score and the parts you will see:

  • Clarinet III plays Bass Clarinet II (and never plays A clarinet).
  • Bass Clarinet I plays only bass (there is no Clarinet IV).

So a total of nine instruments are needed.

  • E♭, D
  • I. B♭, A

  • II. B♭, A

  • III. B♭, bass
  • bass

Note: since D clarinets are quite rare, the player will very often transpose those parts for E-flat clarinet.

  • Thanks. That explains some puzzles e.g. the odd reference to Cl. IV. However, it suggests that the bass players need an A as well as a B♭ instrument. I have heard of but not seen these. – badjohn Jul 8 at 9:01
  • @badjohn Bass clarinets in A have been called for sometimes, but not in this piece – PiedPiper Jul 8 at 9:34
  • But that link says: "Clarinet 1, 2, 3/Bass Clarinet 2 (A, Bb), Piccolo Clarinet (D, E♭), Bass Clarinet 1 (A, B♭)" which seems to be calling for A and B♭ bass clarinets. – badjohn Jul 8 at 10:06
  • @badjohn The link is wrong, there is no bass clarinet in A in this piece. I just looked through the parts: Clarinet III never plays A clarinet, so I updated my answer – PiedPiper Jul 8 at 10:10
  • Thanks again. I will probably listen again and follow only the clarinets in the score but I expect that you are right. – badjohn Jul 8 at 10:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.