4

For instance, is a 13th chord assumed to have an 11th, 9th, 7th, 5th and 3rd along with it unless otherwise noted? And a 9th is assumed to have a 7th along with the triad, an 11th is assumed to have a 9th, 7th, etc.?

  • 1
    When you say "does it have" - do you mean 'conceptually', or 'as actually arranged/played'? Or both? – topo Reinstate Monica Jul 16 '19 at 7:03
  • 1
    Both I suppose, but I mostly mean conceptually. On its own, does it usually imply the addition of the lower extended intervals. – コナーゲティ Jul 16 '19 at 7:42
  • @Dekkadeci I think the "how do you voice..." question relates to how the chords are arranged/played' - which according to OP's previous comment isn't the essence of this question. – topo Reinstate Monica Jul 16 '19 at 11:36
  • 1
    @topomorto - The problematic part is that I'd answer both questions the exact same way. I was adding a comment to one of the answers here when I realized I had a niggling feeling that I'd answered the same question before, so I found it. – Dekkadeci Jul 16 '19 at 12:08
  • @Dekkadeci Do any of the answers on the linked question contain an answer as to whether the conceptual 'definition' of the extended chord does contain all the notes? According to my reading of this question, that's the answer that the OP wants. – topo Reinstate Monica Jul 16 '19 at 12:20
8

Technically, yes.

Extended chords are created by a process of stacking thirds, where you continue to add notes from the scale, proceeding in intervals of a third (of whatever flavour) to the highest note. A 13th chord, therefore, is a seven-note chord that theoretically contains all notes of the diatonic scale.

In practice, however, most often used voicings will not contain all the notes that make up the chord. This can be done due to voice limitations (for example: four part vocal harmonies; only six strings on a guitar, etc.) or in order to clean up the sound - as we might expect, playing all notes of the major scale, say, at the same time can get a bit of a mess.

A typical voicing will include just the main tones - the ones needed to bring the character of the chord accross. For four-part voicings this will usually be the root, the third, the seventh and the upper extension (9th, 11th or 13th). The fifth is usually first in line for omission, but may be included if it is diminished, or if it is necessary for the inversion.

Why these particular tones? The root is fairly obvious, especially when the chord is not inverted. The upper extension, likewise (otherwise we wouldn't know we had an extended chord or what kind). The seventh is a bit less obvious, but it allows us to differentiate between an extended chord and an altered triad - C6 v. C13, for example. The third determines the mode of the chord, so we can tell the difference between, say, C9 and Cm9.

Also worth mentioning, as noted in the comments, is that in certain cases we may wish to omit/include different tones because of clashes, e.g. we would omit the third in a dominant 11th chord (which forms a minor 2nd/minor 9th interval with the 11th).

Other than that, any important alterations - like the aforementioned diminished 5th - should also be included, possibly at the cost of dropping a note we consider less important to the sound of the chord (for example, the root when playing an inversion).

You will notice that such simplified voicings may sometimes appear to spell out different chords than what we're supposedly aiming for. That's ok. One person's C6 (C,E,G,A) is another person's Am7 (A,C,E,G). When it comes to harmonies, context is everything.

| improve this answer | |
  • In 11th chords, the most commonly omitted notes are actually the 3rd and the 9th (at least for dominant 11th chords). For those chords, the 11th and 3rd correspond to notes a semitone apart, while in classical music, I don't recall an extended chord where notes strictly in between the 7th and what the chord is named after (e.g. the 9th in an 11th chord) were kept. – Dekkadeci Jul 16 '19 at 11:13
  • And note that while YOU may have a very firm idea of what notes are correctly in 'G11', there are other opinions! A complete 'pile of 3rds'? F/G? G7sus4, G9sus4? You'll find all of these (and probably others) labelled 'G11'. – Laurence Payne Jul 16 '19 at 16:24
  • I'm a bit confused on why we would omit the 3rd for a Dominant 11th chord. – コナーゲティ Jul 21 '19 at 21:18
  • Also, this question is a bit off-topic, but how come you can have a dominant 7th, 9th, 11th, and 13th but not a dominant 6th? Is it because it has to include a 7th to be a dominant? Also, why can't you have a diminished 6th chord? What if you had a chord like C, Eb, Gb, Abb? What would you call that? Cdim (+5)? – コナーゲティ Jul 21 '19 at 21:39
2

As a really simplified state, the last number note needs to be there. And, since it's above 7, that needs to be there as well. So a 9th will have 7 and 9; an 11th will have 7 and 11, and a 13th will have 7 and 13. Those last three could also be regarded as 7 and 2, 7 and 4 and 7 and 6 - all happily adding to the appropriate numbers!

Of couse, there's the primary triad to consider as well. 1, 3 and 5. So now, there could be a 5 note chord - easily playable on guitar - and obviously piano. As the P5 is heard to an extent in a harmonic of the root, that's the first to be let go. The root needs to be there - otherwise we don't really know what the chord will be called. However - if it's played on another instrument - bass/guitar, Sousaphone, trombone, for example, it needn't be in our cluster of notes.

The 3rd is left in - without it, the chord is neither major nor minor. Back to the 7th itself. There is usually a choice between major and minor here too, so it's important to use the appropriate one. Major 9 isn't the same chord as minor 9. Maj9 will have 1, 3, 5, maj7 and 9, whereas m9 will have 1, m3, 5, m7 and 9.

If we played every note in a 13th chord, it'd be all the diatonics. Often a mess, with clashes certainly between 3rd and 11th, so it's prudent - and necessary on guitar - to leave some notes out. To an extent, it's down to the player, the instrument, and what voicings get used. But, as earlier, simplicity works.

All that, and, the 5s and 9s get altered a lot - especially in jazz. Could be &flat5 or ♯5, so those don't get left out, because they're important to the sound of the chord. Same fate awaits 9ths, so something like C7♭5♭9 will need all the notes,if possible, and on guitar could end up being played on the bottom 5 strings as C E B♭ D♭ and G♭ on top.

So, bottom line. Yes, they could all be played. No, they're not all usually played. Use ears (as ever!) and judicious voicing, and put whatever you feel is best. But at least use my opening gambit as a start point.

| improve this answer | |
2

Sort of. We're all familiar with the 'pile of thirds' textbook examples. And a 13th MAY include the 3rd, 5th, 7th, 9th - but almost certainly not the 11th, unless it's sharpened.

But see this quote from Piston. Particularly note his comment that a 13th may often usefully be seen as a suspension (whether resolved or not). And, if tempted to describe his second example as 'quartal harmony' consider whether it's merely a quartal voicing of triadic harmony.

enter image description here

| improve this answer | |

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.