2

image

What is a notational error in this measure? It is in common time and bass clef. I was thinking that the dotted half note is the problem, but I am not sure how to change it exactly. Maybe to a quarter note + half note?

6

It is mathematically correct, but it tells the world (or at least, people who care about the details of notation) that whoever did it doesn't know much about music engraving, and presumably isn't using software that automatically does such things correctly.

A rest like that should always be written to show the two halves of a 4/4 bar - in other words, a quarter note rest followed by a half note.

For reference, here's page 161 of Behind Bars by Elaine Gould, generally regarded as the "bible" for modern music notation.

enter image description here

Aside from that specific rule, writing dotted rests is generally discouraged except when they start a beat, because in complicated rhythms it can be hard to keep track of the dots. Which of these is easier to read? The second bar shows the four beats in the bar, and subdivides them into 8 half-beats to save the reader having to think about how to count the rhythm. The first bar doesn't.

enter image description here

  • Sadly, more and more music is being written out which doesn't split 4/4 into two halves. But with that rest, after just one beat, especially at the end (there's a double bar line after), is it difficult to read? – Tim Aug 13 at 5:16
  • I'm not 100% agreeing here. The case of 3/2 rest or note on 4/4 or 2/2 bar is acceptable if it does not lead to confusion. I agree about the other things like 1/2 or 1/4 across the middle of the bar. I consider it acceptable if the rest/note starts or ends at a bar end. – yo' Aug 13 at 8:02
1

The rest really would be best to be written as a quarter note rest and then a half note rest. As a band director, I don't think I have ever seen a dotted half note used like this. Very rarely are dotted half note rests used

  • This is already explained in guest's answer. – Your Uncle Bob Aug 13 at 4:09
0

There is no error. The note shown is worth one beat. The rest is worth two beats, and with the dot is worth half that again. 1+3 =4. Job done. What is the question about?

  • There's "Technically valid" and there's "do it sensibly" – Carl Witthoft Aug 13 at 14:23
  • @CarlWitthoft - I guess dv is yours, but what does the comment mean? Read my comment to OP. I feel you're more pedantic than usual today..! – Tim Aug 13 at 15:51
  • You mean your comment to "guest" answer? Anyway, all I meant was that when there's more than one way to notate something, please pick the more common and more easy to read at a glance. – Carl Witthoft Aug 13 at 18:21
-1

This doesn't look wrong to me.

However - is it the final bar of the piece?

If so then you need to look at the start of the piece to see if it started with a complete bar. If it did not (i.e. it started with a partial bar forming an anacrusis) then the length of the final bar is supposed to reflect that and the two together should add up to one complete bar. You say that it is in common time so for example if there was a one beat anacrusis at the start then the final bar should contain only three beats to make a total of four.

Apart from that possibility I can't see the issue.

  • The issue is one of readability – Carl Witthoft Aug 13 at 14:24
-1

As for the time, you have a (dotted half rest) = (3 beats) and a (quarter note chord) = (1 beat) for a total of 4 beats. So the accounting works, no problem.

  • How is this different from Tim's answer? – Your Uncle Bob Aug 12 at 20:07
  • I didn't see Tim's answer. – ggcg Aug 12 at 20:36
  • Tim's answer came after this one. – Wayne Conrad Aug 13 at 0:30
  • 1
    @WayneConrad No it didn't. – Your Uncle Bob Aug 13 at 0:31
  • It's not a big problem, but some questions that make it into the HNQ are attracting a lot of redundant answers from new/occasional users, and I thought we should set a good example by not repeating answers. – Your Uncle Bob Aug 13 at 0:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.