How would you explain the A natural in bar 11? How would you explain that the phrase ends in bar 11 and not bar 12?

Score of *Jesus från Nasaret går här fram*


This melody could be harmonised in several ways. But there's a strong implication that from bar 8 the music moves towards G minor, reaching a cadence in that key at bar 14. Hence the A♮ and F♯. G minor chord has two notes in common with E♭ major, which makes the modulation connected, if somewhat novel. (E♭ major to G MAJOR would be a 'Chromatic mediant', another common harmonic shift.)

Here's a version (I imagine the standard version?) that harmonises in this way.

Music doesn't have to fall into 4-bar phrases. This piece has a 4, 3, 4, 3, 4 phrase structure. Nice, isn't it! Musical traditionalists might be tempted to add an extra bar (or perhaps a fermata) at bars 7 and 14 in order to even it out into 'correct' 4-bar phrases. (More so 100 years ago than now, perhaps.) I'm glad this version doesn't.

  • Yeah, I noticed that 4 - 3 cadence. Makes for a nice "unfinished" feeling internal to the piece. – Carl Witthoft Nov 1 at 12:39
  • How is G minor connected to Eb major? – Hank Nov 2 at 14:16
  • 1
    Eb major and G minor triads have two notes in common. That's enough to make them sound connected. But you can modulate anywhere! There's no requirement to sound as if nothing's changed. – Laurence Payne Nov 2 at 14:21
  • 1
    "There's no requirement to sound as if nothing's changed": indeed, it's rather the point of modulation to sound like something has changed, isn't it? – phoog Nov 2 at 15:53

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.