16

Example: You have d major scale but you make a c flat accidental, does it just naturalize c back to its basic form or make it an enharmonic b? Ive tried searching on google but found nothing. It's like flats and sharps raise and lower notes by a 1/2 step so technically c-flat in the d major scale should be c-natural right? Or do accidentals take the most basic form of the note and then alter it?

  • 2
    It's common to see a natural sign and a flat sign side by side, where the intention is to play a flat note in a key where the note would otherwise be sharp (like C-flat in D major). – Dawood says reinstate Monica Nov 7 at 6:11
  • 1
    Careful, they might delete your question. ;) (Think about it) – Andrew Nov 8 at 20:19
22

The answers so far seem to have missed the point. I think you're asking in a key where there is C♯ in the key sig., and you come across a C note with a flat sign just before it, what do you play.

You'd play a C♭ note - equivalent on most instruments to sounding like a B. Reason being, any accidental changes a base note into sharp or flat, and a natural sign means it gets played as a standard note - one of the white keys on the piano, if you like. A double sharp or double flat changes the note it's before into a note a tone higher or lower, respectively.

Put another way, the key sig. changes particular notes whereas an accidental treats the note as a natural that needs changing in the shown way.

Having said all that, I cannot think of a single reason why a C♭ note would need to be written in key D..!

  • 1
    oh thank you, your answer was well written and detailed to the point where i understand exactly what you mean. – Tanaka Tanaka Nov 6 at 15:55
  • 10
    D dim chord built in the key of D would need a double flatted 7th, i.e. Cb. – ggcg Nov 6 at 16:39
  • 2
    @ggcg - I hoped someone would work one out! Thanks, now I can think of a single reason..! – Tim Nov 6 at 16:43
  • 1
    I hear you. I personally fell like sight reading is easier when the notation follows traditional convention. But then again, that's how I was raised. – ggcg Nov 6 at 21:30
  • 1
    I personally find it easier to read chords when written correctly as the shape made by the stacking of notes immediately tells me what hand shape to use. Changing the cb to a b messes that up for me. – ggcg Nov 7 at 11:37
12

If you are reading a modern edition of the music, a C with a flat in front of it always means C flat, which is the same pitch as B natural.

However in music scores written in the 18th century this is not always the case. For example in the attached violin part (by Vivaldi) published in 1711, it is obvious from the context (as well as from reading contemporary books on music theory and notation!) that the "F flat" really means F natural.

Later on in the same piece there are also some "C flats" that are clearly C naturals.

Note that the rules for how long an accidental stayed force were also different at that time. For example the two F's in the following bar would also be F naturals.

This notation was still in use beyond the death of J S Bach - and was been responsible for a few mistakes in interpretation that survived for 100 or 150 years, when old manuscripts were discovered and republished by people who didn't know about the old notation system.

enter image description here

enter image description here

  • 1
    Interesting. Those 'flat' signs look suspiciously like unfinished natural signs to me! Love the 'double sharp' signs in the key sig. That would make interesting sounds. – Tim Nov 7 at 8:06
  • I'm with @Tim here. I'd love to see how a plain flat looks like there... – yo' Nov 7 at 13:30
  • @yo' I'm not particularly well familiar with this period of music notation, but there are certainly earlier (15C, 16C) examples where flats and sharps were used to cancel each other. This makes sense knowing that they derive from the round and square b that represent the notes a major third above G and a fourth above F, respectively. These were "fa" and "mi" respectively in Guido's system, and as the system was extended with "false" hexachords, the signs applied to other notes to show that they should be "fa" or "mi" in a false hexachord. The natural also came from the square b, only later. – phoog Nov 8 at 17:25
2

I assume standard convention here as opposed to repeating any accidental to each note, where it applies.

A natural sign neutralizes a previous accidental (whether part of key signature or individual), so c# naturalized returns to c, b flat naturalized returns to b.

A repeated sharp to an already sharped note does not accumulate, you still have a simple sharp. (Same for flat). In clean notation there is no alternative to naturalizing before applying the other accidental.

Should you desire a double sharp/flat, this has be indicated by a double sharp/flat symbol. Most probably a simple sharp/flat to the same note came before.

A natural sign is also sufficient after a double sharp/flat to arrive back at the base note.

0

maybe you mean c natural? it is called c natural not sharp or flat. if you play c natural in D major scale then you have played accidental. that's it.

  • 3
    Since to the key signature of D major consists of two sharps, we deal with C sharp, not C natural here. OP is asking, what happens to this C sharp if one adds a flat. – Arsak Nov 6 at 15:11
0

C♭ is always B♮ (in equal temperament)

  • 3
    While this is true it does not answer the question. – guidot Nov 6 at 15:38
  • OP is asking if C♭ can mean something different based on the key signature so yes it does – Legorhin Nov 6 at 15:40
  • 2
    @Legorhin It might help to understand your point, if you added a sentence or two of further explanation. – Arsak Nov 6 at 16:11
  • @Arsak at this point the accepted answer is better than my point so I won't bother – Legorhin Nov 6 at 16:24
  • C♭ is always B♮ in every 12-tone temperament, equal or otherwise. – phoog Nov 8 at 17:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.