3

In the verse part of Genesis' "Behind the Lines", the last line of the chord progression goes:

F C Dm Bb G -> C (resolution)

What is that cadence? What is the theory for that bVII - V - I?

I've heard a lot of times the double plagal cadence that goes IV/IV (bVII) - IV - I, for example in the outro of Hey Jude. But I could not find the correlation between the bVII and V chords. I thought maybe it could be kind of a resolution where D stays the same, Bb goes to B and F goes to G (if voiced and inverted correctly); but it's kind of disorienting that the Bb is chromatic to the key...

  • Maybe because it wouldn't be used in the common practice preiod, there's no official name for it. – Tim Nov 15 at 20:07
  • @Tim I'm not looking for a name but for a common analysis – Iaka Noe Nov 15 at 20:16
  • What is the bass doing through these changes? – Michael Curtis Nov 15 at 20:26
  • @MichaelCurtis that's a very good question, that I don't know the answer to. – Iaka Noe Nov 15 at 20:29
2

Rock harmony tends to be mostly root position, but if the bass held a D for the Dm and the Bb, you could possibly talk about passing motion, especially if there is a line like A Bb B C.

Mixolydian coloring may be the most straight forward way to describe this. Exclude the Bb...

F C Dm ... G -> C

...and you have common progressions IV I then ii V I.

Inserting a Mixolydian (borrowed) bVII between ii and V doesn't really change the essential harmony of root progression by fourths and fifths.

In terms of technical jargon borrowed chord, mode mixture, etc. are terms that could be used.

  • That would be a good explanation. I don't know if there is criteria or theory for passing chords so... – Iaka Noe Nov 15 at 20:47
  • passing motion, chords, etc. basically can be used when the tones don't fit a well defined, common progression, but the linear motion is step wise. A classic passing chord is the V6/4 in something like I6 V6/4 I. Passing chord in invoked for that description, because 6/4 chords (second inversion chords) are expected to be part of a cadence of pedal bass. – Michael Curtis Nov 15 at 20:51
  • Try looking up passing tone, passing chord for a more complete description. Some counterpoint knowledge helps complete the understanding. – Michael Curtis Nov 15 at 20:54
  • 1
    Wikipedia: Borrowed Chord "Chord progressions may be constructed with borrowed chords, including two progressions common in rock music, I–♭VII–♭VI–♭VII, common everywhere, and I–♭VI–IV, used by bands like Genesis, Yes, and Nirvana." – Iaka Noe Nov 23 at 5:17
0

I think it could be considered a line cliché where the A in the Dm chord goes to Bb and then to B in the G chord.

  • I was going to call it that, but isn't a line cliché a progression where only one note changes chromatically (and the others stay the same)? – Iaka Noe Nov 15 at 20:14
  • But it would actually make sense, since then it resolves to C (going A Bb B C) – Iaka Noe Nov 15 at 20:18
  • I don't think it's necessary for all the other notes to stay the same. Stairway to Heaven has other notes move. – luser droog Nov 15 at 20:33
0

The B♭ chord could very well be a borrowed chord from C Minor. In C Minor, it behaves as an ordinary non-tonic, non-dominant chord. In C Major, it will behave the same way.

In any cadence, it's the last two chords that are by far the most important. I wouldn't put any significance on the ♭VII part of a ♭VII - V - I cadence.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.