4

enter image description here

In this music for the violin, the strange sign on top of both E-flat on measure 74 confused me, as I have no idea what it is, and it is not exclusive to just E-flats, as it is also present in an F and a B previously in the sheet-music.

enter image description here

The Piece is Arlington Sketches. What can it mean?

  • 1
    If it's in some kind of tutorial, is it simply pointing out the rule about accidentals? The rule that says even though the low E has a flat sign, the high E ALSO needs one? – Old Brixtonian Jan 8 at 4:18
  • 1
    What piece is this from? As it has “Violin I” as a header, I’m guessing it’s not from a tutor book...? – Bob Broadley Jan 8 at 8:02
  • 1
    Please post the F'n'B part - if they're # or b then Neil's answer works. – Tim Jan 8 at 11:11
  • No, it was not from a book. It was an orchestral piece, and I added the F and B parts, is you would need it. – Newbieviolinist Jan 8 at 21:24
4

The arrows could refer to the finger positions. The first E-flat is low 1st finger. The second one low 4th. If the F you mention is on the E-string it is low 1st, if it is on the D-string it is low 2nd. And so forth.

It is common in violin sheet music to indicate low finger positions with down arrows, especially in music with pedagogical intention.

EDIT: Now that the OP has posted another screenshot it is even more clear that it is in fact low fingering that is the matter as I described above. All those notes which have a down arrow are low finger positions on the violin.

2

Beginners of violin playing are used to learn first little melodies in major on the E, A and D string: the motifs like DoReMiDo will be (analog to Guitar frets) 0,2,4,0.

The arrows above F, Bb and Eb are assigning that the finger position is now lower compared by F#, B and E.

So I agree with Lars Peter Schultz, additionally trying to show the pedagogical intention as reminder of the natural F and the flattened B and E.

0

The down- or up-arrow is often pencilled in by performers to indicate intonation (as in, "this note should be played lower [higher] in pitch than feels natural"). I've never seen it actually used in printed music, but that would be consistent with the context of those four notes in the example.

0

Indeed,as many users have said before me, the arrows were used to indicate a low fingering than usual, which was surprising to me, as the piece was not a beginner string piece. So, the answer came as a shock, as none of my pieces that were of lower level than this piece has the arrows.

Thank you to all those who had spent their time to answer these questions. I appreciate it that you had taken your valuable time off to answer my question. It was helpful to know what the arrows mean, so I can use them as a reference to know what more I am supposed to be playing.

-1

It is probably a reminder of the notation rule that a flat at the same pitch lasts for the whole measure, but any other octaves of the same note have the pitch indicated with their own accidentals.

  • It can not be that, because the note F is also mentioned and that one has no accidental. Anyway check out my answer. – Lars Peter Schultz Jan 8 at 11:53
  • @LarsPeterSchultz - OP says the F and B are previous - not on that screenshot. The question is about arrows. There are no arrows over any other notes there! – Tim Jan 8 at 12:07
  • @Tim yes the question is about arrows and OP indicates that there are arrows above F and B previous (not on the screenshot). I actually wonder whether he means B-flat, because that would make sense regarding the arrows. F and B-flat requires a low finger position but not B natural. – Lars Peter Schultz Jan 8 at 12:34
  • Now that the OP has posted another screenshot it is clear that he meant B-flat and not B. – Lars Peter Schultz Jan 9 at 20:54
-1

I suggest it's telling you which string to use. In the passage that starts D up to A, you'd play those on the open D and A strings.

For the following descending G F E you could then switch back to the D string - but you'd quickly need to change down to the G string to play the C.

So in the first passage the down arrow means that instead of the D string, use the G string for the next few notes. You can then play the descending passage G F E C without needing to change string part way through.

In general, the down arrow means "skip a string" to play the next note.

  • That would be so far from normal notations in violin sheet music that it would require a forword explaining the matter. And if such a forword existed the OP would not need to ask the question. – Lars Peter Schultz Jan 9 at 20:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.