53
votes
Accepted
Can eggboxes really be used to treat a room? If so, how?
The answer is No
Empty egg cartons have lots of problems when it comes to being used as acoustic treatment.
They are a fire hazard! - This should be enough right here.
They only do anything to ...
- 56.1k
34
votes
Accepted
When we press a piano key, why does a high pitch note not run for as long as a low pitch note?
That's true not only for pianos, but for every instrument where a string is plucked, and the reason is basic physics.
When you hammer a string with a piano key, or pick it with your finger, or with a ...
- 6,309
33
votes
Accepted
Piano vs Guitar Strings? Tension vs length?
The best-written summary I could find of this was on Wikipedia.
Technical preliminaries (you can skip this if you don't care)
All chordophones (musical instruments based on vibrating strings) can be ...
- 56.1k
30
votes
Accepted
Why do two identical notes never cancel each other out?
If you play two sine waves of constant amplitude at the same frequency, then the result will be another sine wave. If your two sine waves are in phase, then you have a louder sinewave. if your two ...
- 45.9k
28
votes
Accepted
Is there a broader term for instruments, like the gong, whose volume briefly increases after being sounded instead of immediately decaying?
That's weird... apparently there's no English term for this exact phenomenon, but there is one in German: Einschwingvorgang (pronounced eyn-shving-fore-gung). Wikipedia wants to have it translated ...
- 35.3k
27
votes
Does piano soundproofing require floating walls? Getting conflicting answers from professionals
alephzero's answer is pretty spot on, but from reading your question I think you are buying the wrong kind of product.
In my read, you asked to help quiet the piano for your neighbor. Which was done....
- 1,406
26
votes
Accepted
Trumpet Peculiar Frequency spectrum
Excellent find! Trumpet, as well as the acoustically similar trombone, are very peculiar instruments when it comes to physics. They are cylindrical tubes closed at one end, so they should have a ...
- 22.3k
22
votes
Should low frequency players anticipate in orchestra?
I don't have an answer for you with measurements in milliseconds, etc., but as a tuba player I can give you my experiences.
I'm not consciously thinking of anticipating anything in order to get my ...
- 84k
21
votes
Accepted
Will a marching band on the go sound out of tune to an observer due to the Doppler Effect?
The pitch difference will be very slight, so some very good ears might notice, but it's likely that many of the instruments will be slightly out of tune to a greater degree than the doppler effect ...
- 56.1k
21
votes
Can music time signatures really be irrational?
He's just showing off.
There's a few major reasons why what he describes doesn't matter. First and foremost, sheet music is a guide. It's not actually the music. You are always expected to put ...
- 1,713
20
votes
Is the ear really phase insensitive?
You don't notice the phase of a particular note that arrives in one ear. But the brain can detect phase differences between your ears. That's the main mehod your brain uses to work out which ...
- 1,645
20
votes
Why don't two Boomwhackers with a one-octave pitch difference have a 2:1 length ratio?
Elementary acoustical theory is based on the 'ideal string' with zero mass and no stiffness and the 'ideal tube' with zero diameter.
Real strings and tubes behave slightly differently.
The discrepancy ...
- 90.4k
19
votes
Accepted
Why do listeners hear the lowest note of a chord most distinctly?
The answer lies in the realm of Psychoacoustics and/or Music Psychology. I studied a little of this in Audio Engineering, and from what I remember it has to do with how our primary auditory cortex in ...
- 7,379
19
votes
Accepted
Can music time signatures really be irrational?
I'll give this another spin:
Can music time signatures really be rational?
Which I'd answer: no, not really. Rationality is a mathematical concept, depending on an exact, axiomatic notion of ...
- 35.3k
19
votes
Does the audio an instrument emits above 20 KHz affect how the instrument sounds?
As far as I know up to this point there is exactly 0 scientific indication that any human will perceive music differently due to ultrasonic sound content, no matter what turntable producers want to ...
- 18.7k
18
votes
Accepted
Is 440hz always perceived as the same note no matter the vibrating medium, athmosphere and environment?
The perception of a pitch is due to the frequency of vibration of the hairs in the cochlea (the spiral-shaped organ in the inner ear), which is, in turn, driven by the vibration of the eardrum. ...
- 20.7k
18
votes
Accepted
At what point in history did the relationship between pitch and frequency become well-known among musicians?
If you have access to a good academic library, then the following article appears to be on point regarding the Western tradition:
S. Dostrovsky, Early Vibration Theory: Physics and Music in the ...
- 2,960
18
votes
Accepted
Bridge intonation patterns on stringed instruments
I'm actually planning to make a YouTube video about intonation to delve into this phenomenon.
The short answer is that is depends upon the cross-sectional area of the tension-bearing part of the ...
- 346
17
votes
Accepted
Bass guitar: Fret distance formula
In a 12-tone, equal tempered scale, we want our frequency to double (become an octave higher) every 12 semitones, and we want our semitones to be evenly-spaced.
As each fret represents a semitone, ...
- 45.9k
16
votes
Why are end-blown flutes shorter than their ideal length?
The vibrating air column in the bore extends past the openings of the tube. Any calculation of the pitch needs to take this into account and add end corrections for both ends of the flute. There's one ...
- 19.5k
15
votes
Accepted
Studio monitors: Should we break them in and why?
The only measurements of speaker parameters made before and after alleged break-in periods I could find online support the notion that break-in is almost entirely a myth. The essence is that any ...
- 56.1k
15
votes
How did baroque music sound at the time?
In many respects technological progress in music has been less about the very best sounding better than about it becoming more and more feasible to produce "good" sounds at lower and lower cost.
In ...
- 17.8k
15
votes
Accepted
How did baroque music sound at the time?
There are numerous groups such as The Academy of Ancient Music who perform baroque music using instruments constructed in the same way as baroque instruments (or in a few cases with genuine baroque ...
- 4,752
15
votes
Can eggboxes really be used to treat a room? If so, how?
Your uncle may be a composer, but he clearly is not very knowledgeable about music technology, recording and acoustics.
The misunderstanding comes from so-called "eggbox foam" panels like these.
...
- 4,752
15
votes
Accepted
Does shape of waveform affect sonic perception?
Yes, but not directly - instead, we perceive the different amounts of energy in different harmonics. :)
To illustrate the differences, here are some graphed waveforms, and here's a YouTube video ...
- 518
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible