Is there a reason some guitarists tune down half or whole steps, other than preference or style?
It bugs me sometimes when I would like to play along with a song only to find that it's played down half or a whole step.
I have purchased software that enables me to adjust the pitch of songs without affecting the tempo, etc, and my guitar tab software can transpose tabs, but knowing why artists do this in the first place would be helpful.
Lots of reasons; the most prevalent reason is probably so that they can keep the tune within the range of their voice. Jimi Hendrix was famous for this; tuned a half step down.
Other reasons; to create a different atmosphere in the music; as in the case of Metal where instruments are down-tuned to create the darkest most aggressive sounding riffs possible.
An additional point is that a guitar tuned a half/whole step down will be easier to play with higher action or larger gauge strings due to the less tension on the strings required to maintain the right pitch. I believe I have an interview with Stevie Ray Vaughn around here somewhere where he cites this, as well as many other reasons, as to why he played a half step down.
Another reason is to make it easier to bend strings. A great example would be Jerry Cantrell from Alice in Chains. He constantly bends up a semi or whole tone and mostly all his songs are in Eb standard or Drop C# tuning.
I have done this in the past with 12-string guitars for the simple reason that it makes the high G string last longer! On a 12, the G string has a double that is an octave higher, making it significantly higher and tenser than any string on a normal 6-string. It's always the first string to snap.
Another reason why records don't always seem to be in the expected key is that varispeed recording was very popular at one time. The Beatles used it a lot; Rain was slowed down, while many other songs were speeded up. Strawberry Fields Forever was made of two halves, one slowed down, the other speeded up.
Some guitarists tune their guitar up a tone, whether to fit the range of a vocalist or to get a brighter sound from the tension in the strings. Johnny Marr would do that. (Of course this is far less of a problem if you're playing along as you can just use a capo.)
I was under the impression that drop tuning also makes it easier to do some power chords. For example: dropping the tuning on the E string allows single finger power chords.
The short answer is that guitarists use alternate tunings to make it easier to play songs in keys other than E, A and D.
One example of a reason for this would be to accompany a singer who insists that a certain song needs to be sung in a lower key than the one the guitarist learned it in.
Another example would be when the guitarist determines that in a particular song, he needs to play low notes that are lower than the low "E" on the guitar when it is in standard tuning.
For a variety of reasons:
Advantages:
1) better accomadates a particular vocal range try singing simple man by LS in standard tuning. LS tuned their guitars down 1/2 step.....another good example....several Neil Young songs....down by the river...only love can break your heart. Even neil on occasion, when his range shifts for whatever reason, tunes his guitar down a half step... the song the Joker by Steve Miller is tuned down a full step.
2) makes bar chords and lead a bit easier to play because of less string tension
3) can possibly extend life of strings? maybe? I don't know for sure, but it make sense.
4) Can always capo up to standard tuning, whereas going from standard to lower tunings requites physically retuning your guitar
Disadavantages
1) When asked to sit in with other musicians, re-tuning to standard, if that's what they're using, can be a pain in the ass. Unfortunately, the term "standard" tuning, besides the fact that it is the guitar tuning used most frequently, can play havoc with a musicians ego and/or subconcious. I've heard more than a few musicians, begginners and advanced, speak of "non-standard" tunings as if those who used them were "out of the mainstream" and, as such, were either cheating, or vocally weak. This is easily demonstrated as sheer non-sense when taking a look at the plethora of famous singer/songwriter/guitarists who use, or did use them, routinely.
2) When it's really desirable to capo up to standard, having the capo on the first fret makes playing chords up the neck confusing, because it reconfigures fret markers. Super good players can account for that I suppose, but when I capo up from a half step down, I prefer to capo up to the second fret when possible to avoid these "odd" positionings. If all chords of a song are near the capo (i.e. predominately open as opposed to bar chords), this is not an issue.
3) Does tuning a guitar a half or full step down change how a guitar matures over time? I don't know. It would be interesting to ask the worlds greatest luthiers whether the physics of any particular guitar design pre-supposes that the guitar will be played in standard over most its life.
Well, aside from the fact that they just like it I will admit that there are some songs which sound strikingly different in tone and mood just from a simple 1/2 step down-tuning.
But ultimately, it is my belief that guitarists tune a 1/2 step down in order to make it easier for a piano/keyboardist to play along. Many times when guitarists are working with others in a band or just doing their own songwriting, in regular tuning playing along with a guitarist using a piano/keyboard, one has to be fairly familiar with the piano's scales and chords to play something that sounds good. Meaning, you'd have to be a rather accomplished pianist in order to "freestyle" along with a guitarist. If you didn't know, there's a dirty secret about playing the piano- if you limit yourself to playing on (pretty much) only the black keys, anything you play will pretty much sound good, or at least correct. When a guitarist tunes down 1/2 step, it is suddenly tuned such that it has essentially made the black keys the white keys for the piano player. So, it is my assertion that 1/2 step down is mostly because it makes it incredibly easy to play along with on the piano. Hope this helps.
It's because to make the pitch of the guitar tune agrees with the vocal's pitch :) If one doesn't tune properly , the pitch would sound different . For example playing a 'C' note , and suddenly a 'C#' pitch will be heard . If the vocal sings a C , guitar must play a 'C' too .
Well, I play in dropped A tuning. Why?
The informal reason: The metal band Suicide Silence is the reason I wanted to start playing guitar in the first place and I could not play their songs unless I was in the same tuning as them.
This opened up a WHOLE WORLD for me!
Remember, no matter what tuning you're in, you can always go higher, not lower. Meaning, in dropped A, I can play songs that are in ANY tuning, except for like dropped F which is sooo rare.
Any song I learn, I instantly transcribe to dropped A. I really don't see the need for me to play in any other tuning, to be honest. I play bass guitar, and higher tunings just don't have the "oomph" I need.
Look at it this way: When you down tune a guitar, you are loosening the strings. Which means the strings actually vibrate more when you play and if you pair that with distortion UGH it's amazing. The crunch is unbeatable.
Down tuning was actually founded by jazz and blues musicians. The looser strings are the trick to their play style.
And when you play say, songs that are played in standard but in dropped A, you bring your vibrato and your crunch from the lower tuning with you and create a style that is your own.
I tune my guitar like this: A/E/A/D.
So, I have a lower A and a higher A. This allows me to create melodies with the two strings that I cannot do in other tunings.
Also! The band Motograter (the band Ivan Moody was in before Five Finger Death Punch) has a horizontal bass guitar that they built that only has two strings both tuned in A. So I know when I play that band, I only need to use the 2 strings and it sounds identical! And the melodies are so awesome you would never know they only use 2 strings.
