1

I have a melody for a 90bpm pop song that I wrote but am struggling with the bass line pattern a little bit. It is not what notes to play but what pattern I should use that I am stuck with. I don't have any other instruments except that I know what chords I want to use. The problem is that the melody changes a lot and doesn't have a set pattern so my question is, when you have a complex ever-changing melody hitting a lot of 16th notes and "in between the beats" is it better to keep the bassline simple and on the 8th note divisions of the grid so as to not confuse the two? Most songs have some kind of melody pattern in the lead vocal which is fine but I like only doing that in the chorus and leaving the verses more diverse so the bass pattern is always tough for me because using any 16th notes in my bass pattern (which should remain more or less the same in the verse) always conflicts with some part of the melody. Can anyone give me a hand or tips please?

2

For me personally I'd stick with 8th notes, and put a lot of root notes in it. I've found that the average listener will only focus on a bassline if there isn't any vocals to distract them! (Or if it sounds wrong!) Our singer is amazing so she'll carry the song and I'll only add bass flourishes at the end of the phase when she not singing or holding a note.

It's all personal preference I guess, but that's my two-penneth.

  • you are probably right, with older songs that I wrote, I tried to only use a 16th note in the groove where it fits with the vocal but this one is a bit trickier because the vocal doesn't play on the same 16th notes every bar and a bass line should be consistent in pop as it is there to carry the vocal IMO else it clutters – armani Dec 22 '17 at 17:02
2

The bass pattern depends on the type of song too. If one is writing for a particular type of dance (tango, foxtrot, waltz, rumba, mambo, samba, etc.) the bass line may be written to emphasize the rhythm of the dance. Of course, the individual notes depend on the melodic and harmonic goings on in the music.

The bass is fundamental to making the melody sound good; it should support the melody. In most popular music, the bass shouldn't dominate, especially where the vocalist is being featured. The bass may move around a bit between sections though, to make the listeners aware that something is happening.

The bass should generally stick to chord roots at cadences and other important places within the song. It can move between these to keep the overall impression of activity.

1

Write one bass note per chord. If this feels too static, try two. If the melody is fairly simple, you could write a more ornate bass line. WHY should the bass line remain the same density in verse and chorus?

  • The bassline doesn't stay the same in the chorus but the chorus is easier because it has a set melody that repeats more or less. The start and end notes of the phrases are more or less the same. you can do more with this kind of melody because you can write the bass part for the melody. In the verses I might start the first phrase on the up beat then on the next one I might start on the downbeat of beat 2 and always the 16th notes are hitting different parts in a very unorganized hip-hoppy kinda way. Not sure if I am making sense yet. – armani Dec 22 '17 at 17:07
  • The bass line doesn't have to follow the melody note-for-note. Set up a simple 'groove' and let the melody have all the freedom it needs. – Laurence Payne Dec 22 '17 at 17:11
  • It doesn't and in fact, far from it. But the placement of the bass line should line up with some of the melody notes, do you agree? That is the problem for me because the melody changes from bar to bar – armani Dec 22 '17 at 19:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.