Skip to main content
Marcks Thomas's user avatar
Marcks Thomas's user avatar
Marcks Thomas's user avatar
Marcks Thomas
  • Member for 11 years, 6 months
  • Last seen this week
comment
Why is this C played as an A flat?
@NReilingh: "out-pedantic' is not a verb. Out-pedanted.
answered
Loading…
comment
Parallel Octaves and Fifths in Jazz?
Some do, some don't. I think we may need more context for a better answer.
comment
I accidentally composed a song that sounds like a famous song
@DavidSchwartz: Plagiarism is a special form of copyright infringement; copyright grants authors the right to be credited for their work. The term is also frequently (mis)used in acedemia, where it means something else, but in this context, plagiarism is most certainly a legal issue.
Loading…
awarded
comment
What is the name of this chord? D Eb A
I didn't downvote, because I agree this is a useful explanation, perhaps more so than F7/D (though it's hard to say without more context), but it is somewhat of a non-answer. "What is the name of this chord?" - "Not important."
awarded
awarded
comment
I have a non weighted keyboard, and can't buy a new one. Can I still learn piano using it?
The mention of an organ is relevant, because I think a keyboard without weighted keys does not qualify as 'just a bad piano', it's something else: something in between a piano and an organ. It can still be used to make music and if you enjoy playing it, you should. That goes without saying. However, if your intention is to learn the piano, non-weighted keys are not ideal. I upvoted this answer for highlighting that.
awarded
awarded
awarded
comment
Why does the scale have seven (or five) notes? Why not six?
@BrianChandler: Our eyes have receptors for three different frequencies of light. Our ears have receptors for far more than five or seven different frequencies of sound. I don't think these questions are alike at all.
awarded
comment
Is there a minimum of notes and chords i need to determine the key of a song?
@tim: I think this may vary strongly with the kind of music you're into. The figure in my collection is 72%, but 95%, while clearly an estimate, does sound plausible.
comment
Band rehearsal: how to prepare for suboptimal monitoring conditions?
My argument is that you're tackling the problem from the wrong end. I'd argue not relying on other band members is a flaw rather than a skill. If communication is difficult, for instance due to a lack of monitors, the 'fix' (other than installing monitors) is to communicate better, not to communicate less.
comment
Band rehearsal: how to prepare for suboptimal monitoring conditions?
"I think that's their weakness, they depend too much on each other for timing and cues." I disagree with this analysis. Independance in timing and cues is indicative of an inexperienced band. Expect every gig to be suboptimal. Many problems can be mitigated in some way, but listening to the rest of the band will always be crucial.
awarded
comment
In blues, country blues, why don't songwriters get sued for aping the same progressions/tempos/scales as other established blues songs?
I like this answer, but it oversimplifies with the suggestion that the chords of a song are not subject to copyright. That's often true, but not true in general. International copyright law does not simply put lyrics and melodies in one column, chords and rhythms in the other.