Skip to main content
edited tags
Link
Doktor Mayhem
  • 37k
  • 9
  • 69
  • 159
Post Reopened by Aaron theory
Post Undeleted by Wisdom
rewrote question to differentiate it from similar ones; added [ornaments] tag
Added to review
Source Link
Aaron
  • 95k
  • 13
  • 124
  • 311

enter image description heremordent with and without sharp in the same measure

The first mordent in this measure will be played as D , C# , D. The second mordent in the same measure doesn't have a sharp like the first mordent. 

Will the sharp accidental of the first mordent affect the second mordent since they are both in the same measure? I don't believe that it will but I just wanted to hear your opinion. I believe that the second mordent will be played as D

There is a very similar question (Would an accidental in a mordant still be effective for the whole measure?); however, C the question itself is not specific to this situation, Dand although the primary answer addresses it, it's ambiguous. But I will like

I'm looking for a documented answer to hear your opinionthis specific case. Will the accidental of the first mordent turn the C in the second mordent to C#?

enter image description here

The first mordent in this measure will be played as D , C# , D. The second mordent in the same measure doesn't have a sharp like the first mordent. Will the sharp accidental of the first mordent affect the second mordent since they are both in the same measure? I don't believe that it will but I just wanted to hear your opinion. I believe that the second mordent will be played as D , C , D. But I will like to hear your opinion. Will the accidental of the first mordent turn the C in the second mordent to C#?

mordent with and without sharp in the same measure

The first mordent in this measure will be played as D , C# , D. The second mordent in the same measure doesn't have a sharp like the first mordent. 

Will the sharp accidental of the first mordent affect the second mordent since they are both in the same measure?

There is a very similar question (Would an accidental in a mordant still be effective for the whole measure?); however, the question itself is not specific to this situation, and although the primary answer addresses it, it's ambiguous.

I'm looking for a documented answer to this specific case.

Post Deleted by Wisdom
Left closed in review as "Original close reason(s) were not resolved" by Aaron, Glorfindel, Andy Bonner
added 81 characters in body
Added to review
Source Link

enter image description here

The first mordent in this measure will be played as D , C# , D. The second mordent in the same measure doesn't have a sharp like the first mordent. Will the sharp accidental of the first mordent affect the second mordent since they are both in the same measure? I don't believe that it will but I just wanted to hear your opinion. I believe that the second mordent will be played as D , C , D. But I will like to hear your opinion. Will the accidental of the first mordent turn the C in the second mordent to C#?

enter image description here

The first mordent in this measure will be played as D , C# , D. The second mordent in the same measure doesn't have a sharp like the first mordent. Will the sharp accidental of the first mordent affect the second mordent since they are both in the same measure? I don't believe that it will but I just wanted to hear your opinion. I believe that the second mordent will be played as D , C , D. But I will like to hear your opinion.

enter image description here

The first mordent in this measure will be played as D , C# , D. The second mordent in the same measure doesn't have a sharp like the first mordent. Will the sharp accidental of the first mordent affect the second mordent since they are both in the same measure? I don't believe that it will but I just wanted to hear your opinion. I believe that the second mordent will be played as D , C , D. But I will like to hear your opinion. Will the accidental of the first mordent turn the C in the second mordent to C#?

Post Closed as "Duplicate" by Aaron theory
Source Link
Loading