1

So I'm playing a melody ( synth with a daw ) in D minor key but actually this very simple melody ( mostly made interesting by delay effects on it ) does not touch any note of the key to "prove" it is D minor, since it is playing just white notes.It has a very well defined rest on the D note anyway. When the bass line enter, I used a melody playing between D and C and at that point the whole sound has some weird, but actually pleasant effect. Is there some theory to justify that effect? I some kind of modulation I'm doing between D and C major? This should not be the case because the melody itself sound "minor" even after the bass. Please forgive my ignorance.

2
  • If you could add a bit of sheet music or audio of the music to the question it would help us a lot with giving you complete answers. Commented Apr 26 at 19:17
  • You have given very little detailed information here. You mention a bass line but do not say what it is. Going melodically from D to C can have dozens of possible uses. The white notes contain parts of three different minor scales, A,D and E. Any answer you get will be just speculation without more information from you. Commented Apr 27 at 17:54

2 Answers 2

2

I'm guessing you're in what's known as D Dorian. D Dorian uses all the notes of parent key C major, but roots (tonic, home) on note D.

1
  • Maybe, maybe the bass line sort of confirm the Dorian mode, hence the effect Commented Apr 29 at 6:18
2

this very simple melody ( mostly made interesting by delay effects on it ) does not touch any note of the key to "prove" it is D minor, since it is playing just white notes.

There are three classic types of minor scale. Harmonic, Melodic and Natural. And today we often extend 'D minor' to include any scale based on D which includes the minor 3rd, F. (If it included the major 3rd, F♯, it could be called a Major scale/mode.

Even if we stick to the strict terminology, the first 5 notes of D Harmonic, Melodic and Natural minor scale are D, E, F, G, A. All white notes (6 and 7 are up for grabs). So you can't really say that playing all white notes fails to "touch any note" of D minor!

If we allow the wider definition, 'all the white notes' starting on D form the D Dorian scale, a very common 'minor' scale type in today's music. We can argue over whether a 'mode' is a 'key', but I don't think that's the issue here?

2
  • Just what do you think may be the issue here?
    – Tim
    Commented Apr 27 at 13:01
  • @Tim You feel it's worth picking him up on calling what appears to be D Dorian a 'key'? Maybe!
    – Laurence
    Commented Apr 27 at 19:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.