2

I wanted to design the harmonium sound in Logic Pro and I needed some help. If some of you have idea of how to make the sound, which might be according to me as follows.

There would be a saw tooth oscillator(or many) whose filter is primarily on a low pass and there would be an LFO which will modulate the cut off frequency of the same, with some speed, naturally related to the quality of the sound (Bear the sound in mind). I have tried this approach but could not approach the sound of the real harmonium. Any suggestions please? I am using Logic Pro DAW.

  • I'm torn between this belonging here (since it is closely tied to a specific musical instrument) and belonging at sound design (sound.stackexchange.com) -- but please don't cross post. – Dave Jul 15 '16 at 13:32
2

The waveform from a single free reed is more like getting one "puff" of air each time the reed reaches its full excusion. I would probably start with a square-wave and if possible modify the pulse width down (or up) to increase the higher harmonics. Then I'd apply some equalization (mostly low pass) to round things out and to get the "wigglyness" in the waveform.

The effect that you are trying to achieve with the LFO modulated filter is the amplitude modulation that comes from the multiple reeds that sound when a single key is pressed.

This effect could be (approximately) achieved by using the LFO to modulate the amplitude of the signal (approximately because the beat rate of the modulation will go up with pitch if we assume that the reeds are tuned to +/-XXX cents of one another). This has some advantages in terms of simplicty.

Alternately, one could explicitly model the separate reeds, and put a slight tuning difference between them (on the order of a few cents) to get the modulation. This would allow you to directly model the fact that in most harmonium music, there are multiple reeds sounding when a single key is pressed. Registration changes/differences can also be accommodated in this approach by adding additional, octave separated, generators (probably with different filtering characteristics).

To summarize:

  • starting with a (pulse width modulated) square wave is probably better.
  • part of the sound comes from the mixing of multiple imperfectly tuned reeds sounding at the same time (sometimes even within a given reed bank); this results in amplitude modulation.
  • some registrations involve reeds at different octaves (different reed banks) sounding at the same time.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.