Skip to main content
Music: Practice & Theory

Return to Question

added 83 characters in body
Source Link
wonderich
wonderich
  • 921
  • 6
  • 13

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from "When She Loved Me", ToyStory 2, Sarah McLachlan.

See this for example for the piano:

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as:

musical passage, first time, with E and D in alto voice

musical passage, second time, with E and D in alto voice

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as:

musical passage, first time, with Eb and Db in alto voice

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. The first and second time,Are there good reasons/theories behind these two choices of bases?

the base goes: FEEDDCCBb.

The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBb.

Are there good reasons/theories behind this?

  • The first and second time, the base goes: FEEDDCCBb.

  • The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBb.

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from "When She Loved Me", ToyStory 2, Sarah McLachlan.

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as:

musical passage, first time, with E and D in alto voice

musical passage, second time, with E and D in alto voice

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as:

musical passage, first time, with Eb and Db in alto voice

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. The first and second time,

the base goes: FEEDDCCBb.

The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBb.

Are there good reasons/theories behind this?

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from "When She Loved Me", ToyStory 2, Sarah McLachlan.

See this for example for the piano:

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as:

musical passage, first time, with E and D in alto voice

musical passage, second time, with E and D in alto voice

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as:

musical passage, first time, with Eb and Db in alto voice

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. Are there good reasons/theories behind these two choices of bases?

  • The first and second time, the base goes: FEEDDCCBb.

  • The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBb.

added image descriptions; updated tags; minor proofreading/formatting
Source Link
Aaron
Aaron
  • 95k
  • 13
  • 124
  • 311

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from When"When She Loved Me ToyStory 2Me", ToyStory 2, Sarah McLachlan.

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as:   

enter image description heremusical passage, first time, with E and D in alto voice   

enter image description heremusical passage, second time, with E and D in alto voice

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as:   

enter image description heremusical passage, first time, with Eb and Db in alto voice

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. The first and second time,

the base goes: FEEDDCCBb.

The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBb.

Are there good reasons/theories behind this?

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from When She Loved Me ToyStory 2 Sarah McLachlan.

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as:  enter image description here  enter image description here

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as:  enter image description here

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. The first and second time,

the base goes: FEEDDCCBb.

The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBb.

Are there good reasons/theories behind this?

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from "When She Loved Me", ToyStory 2, Sarah McLachlan.

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as: 

musical passage, first time, with E and D in alto voice 

musical passage, second time, with E and D in alto voice

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as: 

musical passage, first time, with Eb and Db in alto voice

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. The first and second time,

the base goes: FEEDDCCBb.

The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBb.

Are there good reasons/theories behind this?

added 2 characters in body
Source Link
wonderich
wonderich
  • 921
  • 6
  • 13

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from When She Loved Me ToyStory 2 Sarah McLachlan.

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as: enter image description here enter image description here

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as: enter image description here

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. The first and second time,

the base goes: FEEDDCCBFEEDDCCBb.

The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBFEbEbDbDbCCBb.

Are there good reasons/theories behind this?

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from When She Loved Me ToyStory 2 Sarah McLachlan.

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as: enter image description here enter image description here

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as: enter image description here

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. The first and second time,

the base goes: FEEDDCCB.

The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCB.

Are there good reasons/theories behind this?

The two versions of the phrasing and counterpoints of melodies are from When She Loved Me ToyStory 2 Sarah McLachlan.

The first and second time, when this melody appears, it goes as: enter image description here enter image description here

The third time, when this melody appears, it goes as: enter image description here

Questions:

  1. The sheet music says the two parts are all in F major. But are they really the same F major, or are they different?

  2. The first and second time,

the base goes: FEEDDCCBb.

The third time, the base goes FEbEbDbDbCCBb.

Are there good reasons/theories behind this?

Source Link
wonderich
wonderich
  • 921
  • 6
  • 13