0

Two measures from each of two multi-voice piano pieces.

Here according to me the left side time signature is 9/8 and the right side is 4/4. Am I going down the right path or are my thoughts wrong ?

3
  • One important point: You can't necessarily determine a time signature just by looking at the music. You can rule many out, and you can make common-sense guesses (these examples let you do both pretty conclusively). But material in 4/4 and in "cut time" (2/2) would look the same; the difference would be in what is thought of as the beat. Nov 3 at 19:37
  • @AndyBonner while it's true that there will be some pieces, or at least some measures, that could be written identically in 4/4 and 2/2, many will be identifiable as one or the other from internal clues. For example, it's pretty clear that the second excerpt here is 4/4, as I suspect you will agree.
    – phoog
    Nov 5 at 15:10
  • @phoog There's a "high probability" that it is (if for no other reason, simply because common time is, well, more common, and there's no particular reason to suspect 2/2). I just wanted to make the point, though, since this came along as one of a rash of questions starting from the assumption that one can accurately reverse-engineer a time signature by looking at the notes (and confusing time signature with meter). Nov 5 at 15:17
0

You are correct in both cases. In the first excerpt, the easiest way to discern 9/8 is by focusing on the left hand. In the second excerpt, the 4/4 is clearest in the left hand of the first measure and the right hand of the second.

0

Both correct. 9/8 needs to be 3 groups of 3 quavers, as shown slightly less complex in bass clef bar 2.

4/4 is written best when the bar can be split into two equal halves, each containing the equivalent of 2 crotchets. Last bar, treble clef shows two halves, each with just that - 8 quavers. Well done!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.