19

This has been driving me nuts - I can't find a single thing on the net that would indicate why the quarter rest is penned the way it is.

Did it evolve from some initial or abbreviation or was it always a random scrawl?

  • 1
    You might be able to expand your search by using the keyword "crotchet". (That's the British English name of a quarter note/rest. It rhymes with "watch it".) This article mentions it, but it's not exactly satisfying: highhopes.com/musicsymbols.html – trw Sep 18 '14 at 13:56
11

According to Honegger-Massenkeil, Das Große Lexikon der Musik, published in Freiburg 1982 [an 8 volume reference work], the symbol derived from the semiminima rest. This looks like an uppercase-L turned 90 degrees in clockwise direction hovering between the second and the middle line of a staff counted from the top, so I assume the squigly line was probably the distortion of that symbol caused by handwriting.

I found an example in the lilypond documentation here, mirrored below in the middle staff. The first line shows the symbol mentioned by Caleb.

Ancient notation

In this Vivaldi autograph facsimile (Concerto RV 107, Fuzeau Editions 5682) two quarter rests occur, which nicely shows an intermediate form and ilustrates, that the staff position was varied:

Vivaldi autograph

This Liszt-piece, printed by Diabelli 1838 shows not only another form (mirrored z-like), but by showing a combination of the older mirrored 8th rest and a second one rotated by 180 degrees [two eighth rests gives a quarter rest - mathematically pleasing], also suggests this as possible genereration path of the "squigly" symbol.

Diabelli print 1838

  • 1
    Aha! That's what I was referring to in my answer as looking like a backwards eighth-note-rest, or a gamma shape, or (when written quickly) a square root symbol. I didn't realize it had its own name! Although googling for that term doesn't seem to find a whole lot. – Caleb Hines Sep 18 '14 at 17:00
  • 1
    I think you want "180 degrees" there :-) – Carl Witthoft Sep 18 '14 at 19:20
  • Nice. The Vivaldi example displays two of the main trends that I saw in my research -- a downward "check-mark" before the upstroke, and a curved crossbar. The third trend, not displayed here, is a rightward slanting of the upstroke. – Caleb Hines Sep 19 '14 at 13:16
4

I'm not sure exactly when or how the squiggly-line shape came about, but I do know there is an alternate notation that looks like a backwards eighth-note rest (called a "semiminima rest", as guidot mentions). You can see this shape used in early Baroque manuscripts, and it originates in mensural notation. Based on a review of several manuscripts I found with Google image searches, I believe this form gradually evolved into the familiar squiggly line.

First, at the top of this page is an image of a Corelli manuscript that shows the semiminima style of rest. Look at the first bar of the basso continuo part (second staff). Note the rest is somewhat gamma-shaped, exactly backwards from the eighth-note rests on either side of it.

Next, look at this scribbled Bach manuscript of BWV 995. There are several quarter rests scattered throughout, especially in the second staff. They look a bit like square-root symbols. The gamma shape has gained a small check at the beginning, and the upward stroke -- probably difficult to write using the pens of their day -- has now become slanted. The bar across the top is slightly curved.

Next, look at this neater manuscript of Bach's Quodlibet from the Goldberg Variations. In the first full bar, the soprano part begins with a half rest followed by a quarter rest. The quarter rest is a horizontal squiggle, that almost looks like a trill or similar ornament. On the one hand, this symbol can be correlated to the square-root shape in the previous step, by emphasizing the angular check, shortening the upward stroke, and greatly curving the top bar. On the other hand, this symbol looks not terribly dissimilar from a modern quarter note rest, but rotated on its side.

As a later point of reference, here's a manuscript from Beethoven, that shows clear similarity to the square-root shape from the first Bach example. Similar examples can be found in Mozart and Haydn. The symbol is vaguely similar to a backwards Z, and lacks all the fanciness of the Quodlibet example above (which seems to be most similar to the modern symbol).

In this Mahler (look at the first few bars of flutes and oboes), the rest is being written largely the same, as a horizontal squiggle similar to an M, a backwards N, or a partial W (also similar to the Quodlibet, though without the pronounced curve).

Just a caution: this is all speculation on my part, but it seems that the evolution of this symbol was, at least partly, driven by the limitations of the pen technology of their time. I understand that pen nibs work much better when pulled, rather than pushed.

  • Take this analysis with a grain of salt, because it features a small sample size, spread across a range of composers, nationalities, and decades. But it sounds reasonable, at least. – Caleb Hines Sep 18 '14 at 15:03
  • I'm holding out on marking this as the 'correct' answer in the hopes some one comes along with a more definitive answer but much appreciate the effort you put into researching this and definitely consider it plausible - thanks – norlesh Sep 18 '14 at 23:51
  • The Corelli manuscript link is currently broken. This answer could be improved by capturing and inlining the elements of these manuscripts which are essential to it. – MetaEd Nov 2 '18 at 22:40
3

From highhopes.com

"In the 14 th century, the line with a crook attached was called crotchet (pronounced like the crochet lace) which meant crook. The French word for crook was also the origin for the crochet needle, giving rise to the name for crochet lace. This crotchet symbol represents a quarter-note rest."

However, neither there nor at Wikipedia is it clear whether the "crook" was supposed to be represented in the quarter-rest symbol as well as in the quarter-note symbol.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.