1

I am aware of the basic classification of metre i.e.:

-4/4 strong weak strong weak -3/4 S W W - 6/8 S W W S(at least in comparison) W W

However, I am not quite sure what happens with this division if we use other rhythmic subdivisions like:

quarter note|quarter note|eight eight|quarter note (in 4/4)

If we replace the third quarter note with two eights, are they both on the strong beat (or only the first one)? Does the rhythmic subdivision in a given metre has any affect on the strong / weak breakdown?

2

As a sort of basic premise, using your example, 1st crotchet strongest, 1st quaver (of beat 3) next strongest.

However, it depends also on the phrasing, for example, when there's a one beat anacrucis, that makes the last beat in the bar stronger. If that anacrucis starts on the second quaver of 3, then that is strong - even though the 'basic premise' says it won't be.

So, no hard and fast rules, it is extremely subjective - and may well be the case that the same piece will be played with different emphases by two different players - and both will sound good.

1

Simple meters (those with 2, 3, or 4 "on the top") are divided at one level: SW, SWW, and SWMW for duple, triple, and quadruple time.

Compound meters (those with 6, 9, or 12 on the top) are divided at a second level: They are derived from simple meters, typically on a three-for-two basis. That is to say, 6/8 time derives from 2/4, but with three eighth notes per group rather than two. Within each group, the pattern is sww. So we have

compound duple: S(sww)W(sww)

compound triple: S(sww)W(sww)W(sww)

compound quadruple: S(sww)W(sww)M(sww)W(sww)

This may not be important depending on your application, however. One place it comes in is notation: Depending on how austere you want to be, how you notate your notes and rests depends on where it sits in this beat strength hierarchy. In 3/4 time, for instance, one can half a half rest followed by a quarter note on beat three, but a quarter note on beat one is followed by two quarter rests, because "you don't combine a weak beat and a weak beat in a rest". (As I say, it depends on how austere you want to be.)

1

Newer performers can often encounter difficulties with ¾ and sometimes they make it sound like 4/4. I get my beginning students to make the 'one' in ¾ even more pronounced than in 4/4 to goose them into feeling the correct emphasis.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.