11

I noticed that Entry of the Gladiators is said to be in C major scale but I was wondering if it could be in the chromatic scale since it uses all the notes. And if not, are there examples of songs that are considered to be in the chromatic scale?

  • 4
    If there was a 'chromatic key' - and there isn't - wonder what the key sig. might be...Key and scale are not synonymous. Scale is simply an ordered list of notes. – Tim Sep 18 '18 at 7:14
  • Tim, why not turn your comment into an answer? – WarrenT Sep 18 '18 at 14:56
  • @Tim meh I'll leave it in C major. I noticed that the song ends in F major chord though. (?) – foreyez Sep 18 '18 at 16:31
  • 1
    The first part (certainly more than half) of this version is firmly played in C. There is then a key change (rather than a modulation) to F, which is why it ends on F. Wiki's version starts in Ab... Original, not sure! – Tim Sep 18 '18 at 17:02
  • 1
    @PierreTheFermented it wasn't me, I appreciate you trying to answer! – foreyez Sep 19 '18 at 9:56
23

Colloquially, we don't say pieces are "in the chromatic scale," no. We can say that a piece is in C major, or even just in C (not specifying major or minor), but not that something is in the chromatic scale.

One reason this might be so is due to the inherent hierarchy of tonality. If a piece is in C (like your example), arguably the two most important pitches will be C and G. A♯, however, will be comparatively low on that hierarchy. Therefore, saying a piece is in the key of "chromatic" or even "C chromatic" starts to muddy up the hierarchy that gave the piece sense of tonic in the first place. In contrast, saying a piece is "in C" gives us an immediate sense of that tonal hierarchy.

Around approximately 1920, composers such as Arnold Schoenberg viewed the increasing chromaticism of the earlier century (by composers like Wagner, Bruckner, and Mahler) as moving inexorably towards complete chromaticism. This is ultimately what spurred the notion of atonal music, which is music without a tonic. One branch of atonal music is serial music, wherein a piece is constructed using a pre-determined matrix of pitches. (This is a very basic definition, but it works for this answer.)

I say this because, in music without a tonic, we could in theory speak of it as being "in the chromatic scale" since there is no hierarchy of pitches. (Schoenberg famously spoke of the "democracy of tones" in this music.) But still it boils down to the fact that we just don't say something is "in the chromatic scale"; we'd just say it's atonal (or non-tonal) instead.

  • Another composer to check out is Charles Ives. He wrote many songs. While the songs are (mostly) not 12 tone music like Schoenberg, they can be very unusual form a tonal perspective. – Michael Curtis Sep 17 '18 at 20:23
2

"Entry of the Gladiators" is in F in the partitura I have (the instruments in B look like it's in G, of course).

At any rate, it is totally not a piece in "the chromatic scale" since its harmonies are very straightforward progressions for the F major scale. The melody line may look largely chromatic but it is organized in a manner where the beats get in-harmony notes for the straightforward F major progression. If you look closely, you'll find that the chromatic lines constituting the melody line have very well-planned inflection points and sometimes have whole notes there in order to reach target on time.

This continues in the second part (where the bassoons carry the melody): here the first phrase in the bassoon is chromatic but its conclusion, which needs to cover a wider range, is diatonic.

The movements after that are more majestic, meaning that while there still is some chromaticity in the lead, notes are more or less all on-beat which requires harmonies to follow along more. But it's nevertheless mostly straightforward diatonic focus on the harmonies, starting with the Trio in B♭ major.

1

I would say that a piece in chromatic scale, in some circumstances, would be one without a tone, I mean, atonal. Scriabin, for example, wrote some atonal pieces, like his 8th sonata.

enter image description here

The lack of a key signature here does not mean that is in C or in Am.

0

Given that in a standard major key, 7 out of the 12 available notes are pretty well bound to feature in any piece, there are only 5 other notes left and these can be found as accidentals in many pieces of music, often as passing notes rather than something which signifies a modulation or key change.

Unless we're talking atonal pieces, as indicated in some answers, a piece will have a specific key - just like Entry of the Gladiators. The fact that the other 5 non-diatonic notes are found in it as well has no bearing on a 'chromatic scale', even though some parts of it actually feature that same chromatic run as played in a chromatic scale.

Even if there was a 'chromatic key' - and there isn't- what key signature might it have, and why? As in my comment, 'scale' and 'key' are related, but not interchangeable.

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.